Understanding the American Right

What should the USA do about the situation in Libya? Nothing? Impose no fly zone? Something else? Read the article below and comment



Libya Provides Obama and America with Another Conscience Check

Time may be running out to do something to prevent Libyan dictator Muammar Qaddafi from crushing a popular rebellion. While Qaddafi recovered from the initial shock of the revolt, President Obama characteristically dithered over what to do about it. Weeks after even the New York Times editorial page endorsed imposing a no-fly zone in Libya, the administration is finally asking the United Nations to approve such a measure, even though it would almost certainly serve only to salve our consciences, since it will be too little and too late to stop Qaddafi.
Obama’s inaction was to be expected. His administration came into office believing that the promotion of a democracy agenda abroad, let alone supporting regime change in Arab autocracies and Islamist tyrannies, was a discredited George W. Bush policy that should be avoided at all costs. The result of this belief was America’s timid response to the brutal crackdown in Iran following a stolen election and the half-hearted and uncertain reaction to the recent wave of uprisings in the Middle East. The president and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton hoped Qaddafi would be eliminated as easily as were dictators in Tunisia and Egypt, but the Libyan’s grim determination to hold on has provided the United States with yet another conscience check that we appear to be failing.
An unlikely source of some good sense about this strategy comes from the New York Times’s Roger Cohen, who writes today that a no-fly zone is a half-measure that will likely accomplish nothing, just as a similar tactic employed against the Serbs was no bar to the continuance of atrocities in Bosnia. A no-fly zone also failed to help the Kurds in Iraq after the first Gulf War. But like Obama, Cohen’s desire to help the Libyans is overwhelmed by his core belief that almost any American intervention is, a priori, illegitimate. Cohen rightly notes that the Rwandan genocide was made possible because America’s intervention in the Sudan had soured the Clinton administration on foreign adventures. He wonders whether what he considers the “fiasco” of Iraq (since he ignores the fact that American forces ultimately prevailed following the 2007 surge) will allow “rivers of blood” to flow in Sudan. Cohen is right when he suggests that the only viable options available to the United States are inaction or an all-out military push to overthrow Qaddafi. Though he lays out the pros and cons of intervention, it is clear that his disbelief in the possibility of anything good coming from the employment of U.S. power is strong enough to overcome his sympathy for Qaddafi’s victims.
As disturbing as Cohen’s conclusion may be, his column is a step up from the commentary we hearing from most liberal pundits about Libya these days. Of course, anything would sound sophisticated when compared with the ranting of his Timescolleague Maureen Dowd about the subject, but even more considered writers such as Politico’s Roger Simon, who asks good questions about the Libyan rebels, doesn’t consider either the strategic or the moral consequences of American passivity.
The consequences of a Qaddafi victory will be terrible for Libya, but they will also present grave problems for the United States. In recent years, after America’s post 9/11 interventions in the Middle East, Qaddafi raised the white flag after decades of anti-Western misbehavior. He abandoned funding for terrorists, as well as his WMD programs. A post-revolt Qaddafi regime may well return to his earlier predilection for deadly mischief (think the Lockerbie plane-bombing), since he will probably feel, with good reason, that the West will have proved unwilling to stop him.
The decision that President Obama faces is a difficult one fraught with perils. But merely standing by while “rivers of blood” are shed is a poor excuse for a foreign policy, especially when such inaction will also heighten threats to American security. If Obama, and by extension America, fails this test collective test of conscience, it won’t only be Libyans who will wind up paying for it.

No comments: