Egypt's military has suspended the country's Constitution and tasked experts with overhauling its fundamental law.Other countries in the region may also soon be in line for such a make-over - redesigning government institutions, enshrining individual liberties, entrenching guarantees of democratic accountability. But not all constitutions are created equal. Here are a list of six big issues to consider when creating a Constitution from scratch:
Egypt's military has suspended the country's Constitution and tasked experts with overhauling its fundamental law.
Other countries in the region may also soon be in line for such a make-over - redesigning government institutions, enshrining individual liberties, entrenching guarantees of democratic accountability. But not all constitutions are created equal. Here are a list of six big issues to consider when creating a Constitution from scratch:
#6 How quickly should countries write a new constitution?
Russia, a country that's had five constitutions in the past century, has plenty of advice to offer on the wrong ways to go about writing a basic charter, experts say. "Egypt probably shouldn't be trying to change its Constitution just now," says Sergei Alexeyev, an author of Russia's 1993 Constitution and a professor at the Yekaterinburg Institute of Private Law. "Better to concentrate on restoring human rights and freedoms in practical ways and then, after the storm has passed, turn to writing the constitution with a cool head."
If a country takes its time and does it right, it will probably only have to do the job once, analysts say. Most people point to the United States, which has managed with one set of fundamental laws, plus orderly amendments, for more than two centuries. But America's Founding Fathers took a dozen years after the Declaration of Independence before they wrote a basic charter.
"Good constitutions take a lot of time," says Andrew Reynolds, a professor at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, who has been consulted on constitution design for countries including Iraq,Afghanistan, Yemen, and South Sudan.
#5 Does it matter if countries have had numerous constitutions?
Countries that are the most prolific constitution generators tend to be among the least stable: The record is held by the Dominican Republic, which has had 32 constitutions, followed by Venezuela (26), Haiti(24), Ecuador (20), and Thailand (17).
It doesn't matter how lengthy the final document is, apparently. The longest current constitution - almost 120,000 words - is that of India, which is a thriving secular democracy. The shortest is that of the US.
#4 How are constitutions made?
Egypt has chosen to immediately amend a few controversial articles of the constitution, particularly those governing elections, and leave a full rewrite until after the new government has been elected. Parliamentary elections are expected in June, and presidential elections in October.
The proposed changes, crafted by an eight-member committee appointed by the military council governing the nation, were announced Saturday. They reinstate judicial supervision of parliamentary elections and ease eligibility requirements for presidential candidates, opening up the race. The previous laws had strongly favored candidates from Mubarak's ruling National Democratic Party. The amendments would also limit the president to two four-year terms, and require him to appoint a vice president.
The committee went on to limit presidential power by requiring that a president's declaration of a state of emergency must be approved by parliament. It also ended his right to refer civilians to trials in military courts.
The changes will be put to a popular referendum in April. After a new parliament is elected, it will select a congress to draft a new constitution.
Elsewhere, some countries have opted for a constituent assembly, which is like a special parliament of peoples' representatives elected to design the state architecture for a new nation. India's 1950 Constitution was prepared over several years by such a body, as was France's first charter, drafted in 1789 amid the throes of revolution.
#3 Who should be at the table?
But already, pressures are growing to include more minorities, women, and opposition voices. The military has pledged to hold a full public discussion and a referendum on changes in advance of elections.
Inclusion, notes Mr. Reynolds, can help prevent disgruntled parties who might seek to destabilize the new government. In Tunisia, he says, the regime was swept away, so it does not need to be represented. But in Egypt's case, he says, the military still matters, despite having been a part of Mr. Mubarak's regime. "Those [constitutions] that didn't succeed - exclusion is the core principle," he says.
Experts advise against letting a ruling party or leader tinker with the state's basic architecture. Critics allege that Venezuela's 1999 "Bolivarian Constitution" was little more than an enabling device for Hugo Chavez. Three Communist Party-authored constitutions in the USSR did little more than paper over glaring oppression with high-sounding platitudes. "A constitution in Soviet times was like a portrait on the wall. It flattered the leaders but was useless as a guide to real life," says Nikolai Petrov, an analyst with the Carnegie Center in Moscow.
#2 How should power be divided?
Almost everyone agrees that the time-tested model in which three branches of government - legislative, executive, and judicial - check and balance each other is probably best.
But how to arrange relations between them is a matter of some controversy. The US has done well with a president-centered system, in which the executive appoints the government. But British democracy evolved, without a written constitution, according to a model in which ministers must be elected members of parliament.
Struggling Arab democrats might note that many European countries emerging from authoritarianism - including Germany, Italy, Portugal, and Spain - opted for parliamentary supremacy to forestall emergence of a single strong leader.
Many Russian legal scholars now criticize former President Boris Yeltsin, who in 1993 crushed a challenge from his elected parliament and then wrote a new constitution that vested great power in the Kremlin.
Without changing a word, his successor, Vladimir Putin, instituted a far more authoritarian regime. "If I could change one thing in the text that we wrote, it would be to give parliament far more immunity" from the executive, says Constitution author Mr. Alexeyev. "I would make that immutable, not subject to amendments."
#1 Should religion play a role?
However tempting it may sound to legitimate a political regime with religious beliefs, it's a dangerous trap, say experts.
That may be especially true in places like Egypt, where normal political discourse has long been suppressed. Egypt will face debate when it rewrites its constitution on whether the second article, which names the religion of the state and Islamic law as the source of all legislation, will remain.
The best solution, they say, is a secular state that defends freedom of conscience but keeps overt expressions of religion out of the political arena. Separation of church and state "is the only modern mainstream approach," and it's worked in the US and all democratic European states, says Mikhail Krasnov, chair of constitutional law at Moscow's Higher School of Economics.
Fred Weir
© 2011 Christian Science Monitor. Provided by ProQuest Information and Learning. All Rights Reserved.
No comments:
Post a Comment