Understanding the American Right

Former CCBC teacher witnesses turmoil in Egypt
click here to read original article published in the Dundalk Eagle in Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Wednesday, 09 February 2011 12:01
Amira taught Arabic while at college
by Sara Blumberg

    Last year, Mohammed Amira came to the Community College of Baltimore County (CCBC) in the hopes of bettering his English.
    Born in Egypt, Amira grew up with hopes of  one day being a journalist.
    His path lead him to CCBC, where he spent six months not only teaching Arabic, but helping bridge campus cultural barriers.
  
In May of last year, Amira returned to Egypt, hoping to expand on what he had learned while in the U.S.
    Just nine months later, Amira found himself in the middle of a clash between Egyptians and the country’s current  president, Hosni Mubarak.
    Faced with high unemployment and an authoritarian government, many Egyptians took to the streets in protest, hoping to change the state of affairs in their country.
    With the help of social media websites, thousands of Egyptians rallied in Cairo, hoping things would change.
    The protests also left many CCBC staff wondering if Amira was safe.
    Before coming to the U.S., Amira attended the Al-Azhar University in Cairo, the oldest Islamic university in the world. He also received a diploma in international negotiation from Cairo University.
    He came to CCBC in the fall of 2009 as part of the U.S. State Department’s Fulbright Program, which promotes international understanding through fellowship grants to students, scholars, teachers, professionals, scientists and artists. The program allows U.S. citizens to study abroad, and non-U.S. citizens are eligible to come to the United States.
    Amira wanted to study the English language. For Amira, the Fulbright program gave him a chance to better his English and help others learn Arabic.
    Amira said the experience was the first time he had been exposed to an American education system. He admits he enjoyed every minute of it.            His favorite things included the small class size  and the punctuality most students displayed.
    CCBC media relations coordinator Jaquelyn Lucy said Amira worked hard and was an amazing young man.
    “He was full of life; everyone loved him,” she added.
    After finishing the program, he returned home and began teaching. Before coming to the U.S., Amira had taught English as a Second Language (ESOL) at the Al-Azhar English Language Resource Center in Egypt.
    Amira continues to teach there now, while pursuing a master’s program in international development.
    When the riots started Jan. 25, Amira saw events firsthand. The changes worried him, he said.
    “The whole life stopped. I just watched to see if our demands of democracy and dignified life were going to be met,” he said.
    Events in Tunisia sparked the revolt, Amira added.
    Months of protests against poverty, corruption and dictatorship forced Tunisian president Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali to flee the country last month. Not long thereafter, Egypt followed suit.
    “I think what happened was a result of the accumulation of years of corruption, bad treatment of the police, and the injustice that young people faced,” he added.
    In Egypt, Amira attended the Al-Azhar University in Cairo, the oldest Islamic university in the world, Lucy said.
    He also received a diploma in international negotiation from Cairo University.
    He said that before the protests, his students were scared to talk about government corruption, for fear of being prosecuted.
    Since Jan. 25, that notion has changed.
    “I believe they learned now that it was never useless to speak about democracy,” he said.
    He said the protests have encouraged his students to be more expressive about their political views.
    In addition, while the protests have changed Egypt, he worries how Egyptian hopes for a fair government are going to be achieved.
    Currently, the protesters have no leader, which could lead to another dictatorship taking over after Mubarak leaves office, Amira added.
    Though unsure of where Egypt will go next, Amira continues to embrace the changes one day at a time.

Egyptians Say Military Discourages an Open Economy

CAIRO — The Egyptian military defends the country, but it also runs day care centers and beach resorts. Its divisions make television sets, jeeps, washing machines, wooden furniture and olive oil, as well as bottled water under a brand reportedly named after a general’s daughter, Safi.
Ed Ou for The New York Times
A Cairo vendor sells Safi bottled water. The brand is owned by Egypt’s military, which operates a wide variety of businesses.
Multimedia
ROOM FOR DEBATE

How to Have Fair Elections in Egypt

What kinds of electoral systems have worked in post-crisis societies around the world?
From this vast web of businesses, the military pays no taxes, employs conscripted labor, buys public land on favorable terms and discloses nothing to Parliament or the public.
Since the ouster last week of PresidentHosni Mubarak, of course, the military also runs the government. And some scholars, economists and business groups say it has already begun taking steps to protect the privileges of its gated economy, discouraging changes that some argue are crucial if Egypt is to emerge as a more stable, prosperous country.
“Protecting its businesses from scrutiny and accountability is a red line the military will draw,” said Robert Springborg, an expert on Egypt’s military at the Naval Postgraduate School. “And that means there can be no meaningful civilian oversight.”
Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawi, the minister of defense and military production who now leads the council of officers ruling Egypt, has been a strong advocate of government control of prices and production. He has consistently opposed steps to open up the economy, according to diplomatic cables made public by WikiLeaks.
And already there are signs that the military is purging from the cabinet and ruling party advocates of market-oriented economic changes, like selling off state-owned companies and reducing barriers to trade.
As the military began to take over, the government pushed out figures reviled for reaping excessive personal profits from the sell-off of public properties, most notably Mr. Mubarak’s younger son, Gamal, and his friend the steel magnate Ahmed Ezz. On Thursday, an Egyptian prosecutor ordered that Mr. Ezz be detained pending trial for corruption, along with two businessmen in the old cabinet — former Tourism Minister Zuhair Garana and former Housing Minister Ahmed el-Maghrabi — as well as former Interior Minister Habib el-Adli.
But the military-led government also struck at advocates of economic openness, including the former finance minister Youssef Boutros-Ghali, who was forced from his job, and the former trade minister Rachid Mohamed Rachid, whose assets were frozen under allegations of corruption. Both are highly regarded internationally and had not been previously accused of corruption.
“That mystified everybody,” said Hisham A. Fahmy, chief executive of the American Chamber of Commerce in Egypt.
In an interview, Mr. Rachid said he felt like a scapegoat. “People who have been supporting liberal reforms or an open economy are being caught up in the anticorruption campaign,” he said. “My case is one of them.”
“Now there are a lot of voices from the past talking about nationalization — ‘Why do we need a private sector?’ ” he added. He declined to talk specifically about the military but said that in general within the government, “some people have tried to say that the cause of the revolution was simply economic reform.”
Though some Western analysts have guessed that the military’s empire makes up as much as a third of Egypt’s economy, Mr. Rachid said it was in fact less than 10 percent. But economists say that because of its vested interests they still worry that the military will impede the continuation of the transition from the state-dominated economy established under President Gamal Abdel Nasser to a more open and efficient free market that advanced under Mr. Mubarak.
Moreover, the military’s power to guide policy is, at the moment, unchecked. The military has invited no civilian input into the transitional government, and it has enjoyed such a surge in prestige since it helped usher out Mr. Mubarak that almost no one in the opposition is criticizing it.
“We trust them,” said Walid Rachid, a member of the April 6 Youth Movement that helped set off the revolt. “Because of the army our revolution has become safe.”
Some of the young revolutionaries at the vanguard of the revolt identify themselves as leftists or socialists. And the idea of liberalizing the economy was thrown into disrepute because of the corrupt way that the Mubarak government carried out privatization, bestowing fortunes on a small circle around the ruling party while leaving most Egyptians struggling against grinding poverty and rampant inflation.

Do You Still Trust that the Egyptian Military Will Keep its Promises and Make the Governmental Changes the Protestors Demanded? Do you Believe the Military is Corrupt? Do you Support Capitalism and a Free-Market Economy or a State-Dominated Economy? Why? comment below


Egypt’s Missing Stir Doubts on Military’s Vows for Change

CAIRO — Ramadan Aboul Hassan left his house one night about three weeks ago to join a neighborhood watch group with two friends and did not return. The next time their relatives saw the three men they were emerging Wednesday night from a maximum security prison, 400 miles from home, run by Egypt’s military. Some family members said they bore signs of torture, though others denied it.
Ed Ou for The New York Times
Ramadan Aboul Hassan, left, and Ahmed Aboul Hassan vanished with a friend last month and ended up in a far-off prison.
Multimedia
ROOM FOR DEBATE

How to Have Fair Elections in Egypt

What kinds of electoral systems have worked in post-crisis societies around the world?
While many here have cheered the military for taking over after last week’s ouster of President Hosni Mubarak and for pledging to oversee a transition to democracy, human rights groups say that in the past three weeks the military has also played a documented role in dozens of disappearances and at least 12 cases of torture — trademark practices of the Mubarak government’s notorious security police that most here hoped would end with his exit.
Some, like Mr. Aboul Hassan and his two friends, were not released until several days after the revolution removed Mr. Mubarak.
Now human rights groups say the military’s continuing role in such abuses raises new questions about its ability to midwife Egyptian democracy.
“The military is detaining people incommunicado, which is illegal, and so it is effectively disappearing people,” said Heba Morayef of Human Rights Watch, which has documented four cases that it describes as involving torture. Amnesty International has documented three such cases, and the Front for the Defense of Egyptian Protesters has documented five.
Human Rights Watch has also documented one case in which the military transferred a prisoner to the country’s feared State Security forces, where it says he was tortured.
Ms. Morayef said the cases of detention and torture did not appear to be “systematic,” but added, “It is enough to set off alarm bells and call for an investigation into abuses by the military police.”
Most victims were arrested by the military, she says, though two were detained by neighborhood watch groups and then handed over to soldiers. The interrogations accompanying abuse all revolved around victims’ suspected participation in the antigovernment protests that toppled the Mubarak government.
Hundreds of unidentified bodies have shown up at hospitals around the country, says the Front for the Defense of Egyptian Protesters, deepening the uncertainty. On Wednesday, Egypt’s Health Ministry reported that 365 had died during the uprising and that 5,500 were injured.
Military officials said at a meeting of youth activists on Monday that they would search for those who had disappeared during the uprising, and confirmed that at least 77 people had been detained in fighting in Tahrir Square, according to notes of the meeting published on Facebook.
Local media reported that the army chief of staff, Sami Enan, had agreed to release all of those detained during the revolution, but rights groups complain that he did not commit to a timetable. They have seen little movement toward fulfilling the pledge.
Ramadan Aboul Hassan, 33, vanished well after the battle with the police around Tahrir Square had ended. On Jan. 29, after the police fled the city and the military stepped in, Ramadan left home with his nephew Ahmed Aboul Hassan, 22, and their friend Mostafa Mahrous Mostafa to join neighbors in fending off looters. Then they disappeared.
For 18 days Mohamed Aboul Hassan, 51, Ramadan’s eldest brother, worked the phones, each call introducing him to a new lieutenant or government bureaucrat offering a different story about the men’s whereabouts and counseling a different course of action.
The family combed hospitals and police stations and begged military officials they managed to get on the phone. They asked the national prison authority if the men’s names were in the country’s database of inmates, and were told they were nowhere to be found.
Five days after the disappearance, their families learned that the men had been arrested by the military under a bridge on nearby Revolution Street close to the local headquarters of military intelligence. Mohamed was called in to the intelligence office, given their national ID cards and asked to sign for them before he could take the cards home. He was not told why they had been arrested or when they would be released.
“I don’t understand why the government is doing this,” Mohamed said Tuesday, the height of the search. “If they would just give me some piece of information about them, it would mean so much for me.”
The military has little experience directly governing and policing the civilian population, leaving it ill equipped for tasks like notifying families of arrests or detentions, said Ahmed Ragheb, the executive director of the Hisham Mubarak Law Center, a human rights organization. “The army is not prepared to operate an incarceration system or facilities.”
Mohamed Fadel Fahmy, Enas Muthaffar and Dawlat Magdy contributed reporting.

Talkin' bout a Revolution

Created in July 2010 after talking with Egyptian students about possibility of revolution in Egypt but I was afraid to post it then cause I thought it might get me in trouble.
Aint afraid now!
 


Find guide to revolution here:
From Dictatorship to Democracy by Gene Sharp

OP-ED COLUMNIST

What Egypt Can Teach America

It’s a new day in the Arab world — and, let’s hope, in American relations to the Arab world.
Damon Winter/The New York Times
Nicholas D. Kristof

On the Ground

Share Your Comments About This Column
Nicholas Kristof addresses reader feedback and posts short takes from his travels.
Go to Columnist Page »

Related

The truth is that the United States has been behind the curve not only in Tunisia and Egypt for the last few weeks, but in the entire Middle East for decades. We supported corrupt autocrats as long as they kept oil flowing and weren’t too aggressive toward Israel. Even in the last month, we sometimes seemed as out of touch with the region’s youth as a Ben Ali or a Mubarak. Recognizing that crafting foreign policy is 1,000 times harder than it looks, let me suggest four lessons to draw from our mistakes:
1.) Stop treating Islamic fundamentalism as a bogyman and allowing it to drive American foreign policy. American paranoia about Islamism has done as much damage as Muslim fundamentalism itself.
In Somalia, it led the U.S. to wink at a 2006 Ethiopian invasion that was catastrophic for Somalis and resulted in more Islamic extremism there. And in Egypt, our foreboding about Islamism paralyzed us and put us on the wrong side of history.
We tie ourselves in knots when we act as if democracy is good for the United States and Israel but not for the Arab world. For far too long, we’ve treated the Arab world as just an oil field.
Too many Americans bought into a lazy stereotype that Arab countries were inhospitable for democracy, or that the beneficiaries of popular rule would be extremists like Osama bin Laden. Tunisians and Egyptians have shattered that stereotype, and the biggest loser will be Al Qaeda. We don’t know what lies ahead for Egypt — and there is a considerable risk that those in power will attempt to preserve Mubarakism without Mr. Mubarak — but already Egyptians have demonstrated the power of nonviolence in a way that undermines the entire extremist narrative. It will be fascinating to see whether more Palestinians embrace mass nonviolent protests in the West Bank as a strategy to confront illegal Israeli settlements and land grabs.
2.) We need better intelligence, the kind that is derived not from intercepting a president’s phone calls to his mistress but from hanging out with the powerless. After the 1979 Iranian revolution, there was a painful post-mortem about why the intelligence community missed so many signals, and I think we need the same today.
In fairness, we in the journalistic community suffered the same shortcoming: we didn’t adequately convey the anger toward Hosni Mubarak. Egypt is a reminder not to be suckered into the narrative that a place is stable because it is static.
3.) New technologies have lubricated the mechanisms of revolt. Facebook and Twitter make it easier for dissidents to network. Mobile phones mean that government brutality is more likely to end up on YouTube, raising the costs of repression. The International Criminal Court encourages dictators to think twice before ordering troops to open fire.
Maybe the most critical technology — and this is tough for a scribbler like myself to admit — is television. It was Arab satellite television broadcasts like those of Al Jazeera that broke the government monopoly on information in Egypt. Too often, Americans scorn Al Jazeera (and its English service is on few cable systems), but it played a greater role in promoting democracy in the Arab world than anything the United States did.
We should invest more in these information technologies. The best way to nurture changes in Iran, North Korea and Cuba will involve broadcasts, mobile phones and proxy servers to leap over Internet barriers. Congress has allocated small sums to promote global Internet freedom, and this initiative could be a much more powerful tool in our foreign policy arsenal.
4.) Let’s live our values. We pursued a Middle East realpolitik that failed us. Condi Rice had it right when she said in Egypt in 2005: “For 60 years, my country, the United States, pursued stability at the expense of democracy in this region, here in the Middle East, and we achieved neither.”
I don’t know which country is the next Egypt. Some say it’s Algeria, Morocco, Libya, Syria or Saudi Arabia. Others suggest Cuba or China are vulnerable. But we know that in many places there is deep-seated discontent and a profound yearning for greater political participation. And the lesson of history from 1848 to 1989 is that uprisings go viral and ricochet from nation to nation. Next time, let’s not sit on the fence.
After a long wishy-washy stage, President Obama got it pitch-perfect on Friday when he spoke after the fall of Mr. Mubarak. He forthrightly backed people power, while making clear that the future is for Egyptians to decide. Let’s hope that reflects a new start not only for Egypt but also for American policy toward the Arab world. Inshallah.
•
I invite you to comment on my blog, On the Ground. Please also join me on Facebook, watch my YouTube videos and follow me on Twitter.