Dear President Obama,
Monday night, after 7 hours at the Cairo airport, myself and 25 other American English teachers were evacuated from Egypt on charter flights from a private terminal. On arrival in Athens, we were greeted on the tarmac by the US ambassador to Greece, embassy officials gave us food, water, and directed us to transportation and hotels. The US State Department was efficient, professional and got us all out safely and comfortably and for that I am grateful. They did what government should do for its people and I thanked God I was lucky enough to be born American. Of course my Egyptian friends and co-workers that I left behind to fend for themselves are not so lucky. My co-worker Yara, who called me, terrified on Saturday night with gunfire outside her building, alone in her apartment as her mild-mannered pharmacist husband defended neighborhood homes and businesses armed only with sticks and his dignity. My bleary-eyed co-worker Mahmoud, who said he could not join the protest because his brother was already out on the streets and his mother would not be able to handle the anxiety by herself. Mahmoud could not bring himself to tell his mother that his brother had been tasked with the incredibly dangerous, but vital, job of protecting a prison. Our assistant Heshaam, who was badly shaken up after his neighborhood militia beat a looter to death in front of him. My student Mohammed Hamdy, who left Cairo to defend his family's home in the small town of Kafr El-Sheik and called to check if I was OK and plead with me not to go out on the streets after dark. The Egyptian hotel employees, who when asked by frantic Americans if we were safe, explained with a caring, reassuring smile how many men armed with sticks and crowbars were in front of the hotel and their yellow armband system to distinguish their own from looters and criminals at a distance. The strangers on the street, who made us promise to go back to our hotel as the 4 pm curfew neared. These are a few of the people I left behind in Egypt.
Monday night, after 7 hours at the Cairo airport, myself and 25 other American English teachers were evacuated from Egypt on charter flights from a private terminal. On arrival in Athens, we were greeted on the tarmac by the US ambassador to Greece, embassy officials gave us food, water, and directed us to transportation and hotels. The US State Department was efficient, professional and got us all out safely and comfortably and for that I am grateful. They did what government should do for its people and I thanked God I was lucky enough to be born American. Of course my Egyptian friends and co-workers that I left behind to fend for themselves are not so lucky. My co-worker Yara, who called me, terrified on Saturday night with gunfire outside her building, alone in her apartment as her mild-mannered pharmacist husband defended neighborhood homes and businesses armed only with sticks and his dignity. My bleary-eyed co-worker Mahmoud, who said he could not join the protest because his brother was already out on the streets and his mother would not be able to handle the anxiety by herself. Mahmoud could not bring himself to tell his mother that his brother had been tasked with the incredibly dangerous, but vital, job of protecting a prison. Our assistant Heshaam, who was badly shaken up after his neighborhood militia beat a looter to death in front of him. My student Mohammed Hamdy, who left Cairo to defend his family's home in the small town of Kafr El-Sheik and called to check if I was OK and plead with me not to go out on the streets after dark. The Egyptian hotel employees, who when asked by frantic Americans if we were safe, explained with a caring, reassuring smile how many men armed with sticks and crowbars were in front of the hotel and their yellow armband system to distinguish their own from looters and criminals at a distance. The strangers on the street, who made us promise to go back to our hotel as the 4 pm curfew neared. These are a few of the people I left behind in Egypt.
My Purpose in Egypt
For the last 18 months on a State Department fellowship, I have been teaching English to Ph.D. students at Al Azhar University in Cairo as a means to the overarching goal of promoting mutual understanding between Americans and Muslims in Egypt. Every day I dealt firsthand with the political backdrop of tension between America and the Muslim World. In the classroom, I had countless hours of heated discussions, confronting anti-American stereotypes, conspiracy theories, misinformation and festering resentment, even rage, at the American destruction of Iraq and support of Israel. I neither defended nor apologized for American actions and policies. I sought only to help my Egyptian students better put themselves in Americans' shoes and understand American thinking and actions. Most successful in opening the minds and pacifying the anger of my more belligerent students was demonstrating that what they hate about Americans' tendencies – collectively blaming all Muslims for the actions of terrorists, being owned by stereotypes and ignorance of what Islam is, and judging Muslims by American cultural standards – exactly parallels their own collective blame, stereotypes, ignorance and judgment of Americans. In realizing that at their most angry and self-righteous, they become what they hate, hate began to evaporate. No matter how tense, every discussion ended with a handshake, affirming my conviction that it is possible for Americans and Muslims to communicate and put out the flames of hatred while building understanding and respect for one another. My Inspiration
In his “historic” Cairo speech in 2009, Obama's idealism inspired me, and gave me the vision that led me to Cairo later that year. In his Cairo speech, Obama proclaimed “...just as America can never tolerate violence by extremists, we must never alter or forget our principles. Nine-eleven was an enormous trauma to our country. The fear and anger that it provoked was understandable, but in some cases, it led us to act contrary to our traditions and our ideals.” Obama continued “...I do have an unyielding belief that all people yearn for certain things: the ability to speak your mind and have a say in how you are governed; confidence in the rule of law and the equal administration of justice; government that is transparent and doesn't steal from the people; the freedom to live as you choose. These are not just American ideas; they are human rights. And that is why we will support them everywhere... power through consent, not coercion.” How bitterly ironic that our first black president – after the ignominy of the 3/5ths compromise and “separate but equal” – has forgotten history and is backing a policy toward Egypt so similarly contrary to American ideals and the charted course of destiny. Forgetting Our Principles
President Obama, I literally cried tears of joy the night you were elected and I was a soldier on the front lines carrying out exactly the mission you articulated in Cairo. Again and again, I swore to my Egyptian students that they were wrong about America, that America is synonymous not with self-interest and greed, but with magnanimity and justice – that at bottom our common humanity unites us more than our differences divide us. But as I boarded a plane in Cairo abandoning my Egyptian brothers and sisters to save myself I could not quiet the thought that they were right and I was naive. President Obama, my father taught me to live an honest life and by not calling for Mubarak's resignation you turned me into a liar. All of my work for mutual understanding is negated a million times over by Hillary Clinton's initial support of the Mubarak regime and multiplied by your indecisiveness. You can hide behind Robert Gibbs's squirming, spurious and disingenuous “Egypt's fate is not for America to decide” but rest assured that you do not fool a single Egyptian. Mubarak has slaughtered his own people, he has sacrificed his people's safety to maintain power; pulling all his police from the streets and allowing prison breaks, sowing chaos in the hope that the resulting popular terror would supply him with the pretext to crack down. He has cut internet and cell phone service. You are allied to a war criminal. He has demonstrated his willingness to destroy his own country only to hold on to power, or even if he can't he will destroy it only out of spite. You are allied to the Egyptian Saddam and if you unequivocally withdraw support he will be gone within 24 hours. It is for you to decide. You made a promise to the Egyptian people that you would support them and Egypt's fate is in now your hands. Why do you think the protestors signs are in English? Who do you think they are talking to? Egypt After Mubarak
President Obama, even with such an obvious moral equation, the world knows that pragmatically you are gripped by legitimate fear as you contemplate a post-Mubarak Egypt and a Middle East in turmoil. By not calling for Mubarak to resign after the people have overwhelmingly voted against him with their feet, after he has shown his ruthlessness and disdain for decency and all the values America claims to stand for – you are providing fodder for the next generation of terrorists and disgracing America. Of course, it would have been better for stability for Mubarak to have implemented reforms but that window of opportunity has closed. Every day you wait to call for Mubarak to resign, the Egyptian people's trauma and suffering continues, the Egyptian economy hemorrhages millions, and the heart of the Arab world takes a major, radicalizing leap backward in development. Broker a deal today with Omar Suleiman, Mohammed El Baradei, Amr Moussa, Gamal Ganzouri and the military's approval that guarantees peace with Israel. Include a small handful of other opposition and youth leaders and convene a constitutional convention. Set the date of parliamentary and presidential elections without incumbents. Simultaneously, ensure a launch of food subsidies and a blitz of construction of new schools and hospitals and a retraining of police forces. Egypt will take a while to calm down but it will calm down if and only if Mubarak goes. President Obama, the time is now, Egypt has grown up in the last 8 days and is no longer the same country. Ultimately you must trust in the moderation and sense of the Egyptian people. You would do well to remember that the younger generation started this revolution and if an Islamist regime ever did come into power that same internet-savvy youth generation is your guarantee that if oppressed, the people will rise again and demand change. History is still being written and the pen is in your hand, talk of an “orderly transition” is a huge step but it lacks the certainty and moral authority of openly and loudly calling for Mubarak's resignation. President Obama, tear down this regime!
1 comment:
Thank you.
Egypt is my love, my heart, my country, and my choice for ever.
I and all egyptians only ask ALLAH to save us. All of us know that no one except ALLAH will save and protect us. see you soon and I will remind you.
Post a Comment