|
Links to Middle East, Latin-American and International Media, Blogs, Think Tanks, Universities and Advocacy Orgs (and a hodgepodge of vids)
Understanding the American Right
US Red Media
My response to Abdurraheem Green's Email
Abdurraheem Green's Response to my Email
From: Abdurraheem Green
Subject: Re: Coca-Cola Muslim Generation
To: "Benjamin Kalt"
Date: Tuesday, February 8, 2011, 3:08 PM
Subject: Re: Coca-Cola Muslim Generation
To: "Benjamin Kalt"
Date: Tuesday, February 8, 2011, 3:08 PM
Funny that you think I was targeting this all at America, since I
wasn't. It was the West in general. Anyway if the cap fits as they
say, wear it!
The West is defined by itself, by its materialistic and consumer
culture. You'd have to be blind or stupid or maybe both to deny it! If
you want to see how the West defines itself, read the magazines, and
watch the movies! I'm sure you do anyway. There you have it!
Let's take a few of your own examples to see how silly your comments really are:
How about this by the Beatles:
The best things in life are free
But you can keep 'em for the birds and bees
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want
Your lovin' give me a thrill
But your lovin' don't pay my bills
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, oh yeah
That's what I want
Money don't get everything, it's true
What it don't get, I can't use
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want
Money don't get everything, it's true
What it don't get, I can't use
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want
Now give me money
A lot of money
I wanna be free
Oh, outta my head
That's what I want, oh yeah
Now give me money
A lot of money
Oh yeah, I need money
Oh now give me money
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want!
Hey, and I really couldn't be bothered to go through the rest of
Alicia Keys songs, but I don't even need to because "If I ain't Got
You (Alicia Keys)" which you claim "completely rejects materialism"
doesn't at all! In fact this song so perfectly proves my point that
you Benjamin are so affected by the materialistic ideas of the West
that you think passionate love and devotion to another human being
(which the song is so obviously about) is not materialistic, but if
you actaully tried to understand my lecture you'd have realised its
all about how we are deluded by this world, and its glitter and we
have lost our connection with Allah, the Almighty, and it is only in
knowing Him that we will find true peace. We look for happiness in the
things of this world, whereas trying to find happiness in the things
of this world is real cause of our misery and misguidance.
Sure there are people with morals, a deep commitment to justice, even
ascetics, peace activist, environmentalists, real practising
Christians, and indeed Muslims who consider themselves part of the
West, as in fact I do, who do not conform to the hedonistic culture,
and do not consider mere material gratification the means to happiness
and success. There are of course parts of Western culture also that
run counter to the general ethos that prevails (although I would argue
that this is due to tattered remnants of Divine Guidance that is still
remaining. I will go as far as to in some respect (and I have talked
about this in many other lectures) where the West is in fact committed
to superior moral values that those that can be found in the Muslim
world at this time. However, I would argue that hedonism and
materialism fundamentally defines the West today and it is how most
western people define themselves in their attitudes and practices.
When I say most, I mean by far the greatest number. So although it is
a generalization, it is justified.
You get even more confusing in your critique when you imply that my
specific examples of certain sexual acts are intended to be generally
true! The only one being plainly dishonest here is you!
Did I read you were an English teacher? Oh dear! I'm very worried for
the students at Al Azhar.
You highlight that the critics of following one's desires are many,
but this in fact proves my point, since they, like me have acknowledge
the hedonistic individualism of modern Western culture! My comments
about the Consumer Society and Capitalism specifically can be found
being made by many Westerners! Try reading Marx for starters :) The
Shock Doctrine, by Naomi Klein. If you have any doubts about the evils
of capitalism as promoted mostly by the USA watch this documentary
called "The Corporation" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pin8fbdGV9Y
The funny thing about your critique is that it guilty of what it
accuses of i.e. generalizations, and a failure to understand, mixing
truth and falsehood.
Interestingly while you yourself talk about generalizations you make a
massive generalization about me when you call me primarily and
entertainer, not a scholar. I wonder how many of my lectures you have
listened to or articles you have read to make such a generalization,
which I find in fact quite insulting.
Please watch this set of lectures: The Proof that Islam is the Truth
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOwA0v026wY
or for something more scholarly read this:
http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/uncomfortable_questions__an_authoritative_exposition__by__abdur_raheem_green_
I am primary in fact a teacher and educator. What I spend a lot of
time and effort doing is taking complex concepts and ideas and
transforming them into simple concepts that people can relate to and
understand... and guess what that involves doing a lot of the time? It
involves making generalizations. Yes, of course it's not 100%
accurate, but is not 100% accurate when our science teachers explain
the model of the atom with reference to the solar system. No, but
that's how we manage to understand complex models, by connecting them
to simpler ones that people understand.
Perhaps some nuclear physicist would belittle this teachers efforts,
and even call it "entertainment." Most of us would say that this
physicist needs to get a life!
We humans always speak and talk in generalizations, as does God in His
last and final message, the Quran, as do Christian, Hindu, Buddhist
and Jewish scriptures.
Let's take the beatitudes from the Gospels for example:
"Blessed are the mourners for they shall be comforted"
Well has EVERY mourner been comforted. Millions haven't! So this a
generalization, and so Jesus is wrong using your approach.
and how about...
"Blessed are the peace makers they shall be called sons of God."
Well I never heard Gandhi being called that! Actually not even mother
Teresa. In fact it leaves out women altogether since they must surely
be daughters not sons. Can't be right then!.
Let's take another generalization from Jesus:
"Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye devour
widows' houses, and for a pretence make long prayer: therefore ye
shall receive the greater damnation. (Matthew 23:14)”
So Jesus just called every Pharisee and Scribe hypocrites! That's a
massive generalization. Talk about preaching hate!
It is blindingly obvious that a generalization does not include
everyone, and when one is being made (a generalization that is) it
doesn't mean to include everyone.
What becomes increasingly entertaining in your comments is how you go
on to offer yourself as an American who is not like my description.
It reminds me of a friend of mine who insisted that smoking couldn't
be bad because his grandfather smoked twenty a day and lived healthily
until he was eighty!
Another important point is context, and to be fair there is no way for
you to know this.
My lecture was never aimed at, nor did I expect it to be listened to
by students in Al Azhar who might interpret this as an anti Western
hate tirade (and I really doubt they do anyway). It was aimed a group
of Muslims living in Australia trying to hang on to some remnants of
their religion in the consumer society. Although I think the lessons
from my lecture ring true to many. If Muslims have lost their
connection with the true source of inner peace, which is remembrance
of Allah, it is in part because they are victims of it, not because,
as in the case with the West, because they are the propagators of it.
Now when your comments become comical, but sadly not amusing in the
least is when you suggest that my lecture is the sort of thing that
spreads misunderstanding and this hatred about America, and you equate
it with how Islam is misrepresented in the West. Of course you have
cleverly pre-empted the obvious thought that those who might bother to
read your comments will have, which is of course: "Well this
Abdurraheem is from the West, He is educated there and understands
Western society well!" And I'd like to confirm to your readers that
they are in fact entirely correct in this assumption. In fact it might
even interest them more that I had reached many of these conclusions
about the West and its economic system before I became Muslim!
Now the reason this is comical is because the analogy of comparing
misrepresentation of the USA with the misrepresentation of Islam is
false (any of you studying fiq will understand qiyas baatil) is
because Islam is a religion, philosophy and ideology. America and the
West are geographical locations. My critic is of the predominant
ideology of the West, consumerism and by extension capitalism, and the
hedonistic culture attached to it, not of America, the USA per-say.
The real image problem for America is not because of people like me
saying what I do, but more likely because of America's unflinching and
almost blind support for Israel, it's illegal invasion of Muslim
lands, causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Muslim
civilians, it's continued financial and military support for despotic
dictators through out the world, including the Muslim world.
You say that you want to lern, but if that is the case you need to
listen. How many though have ears that hear, but they are deaf, and
how many have eyes that can see but they are blind, and how many
tongues that speak and fingers that type, but they might as well be
dumb!
As for you final story, well there's a really nice thing that can be
found in the gospels the Jesus is supposed to have said:
"Take the log out your own eye, before you take the twig out of others!"
The story my friend applies most to you!
wasn't. It was the West in general. Anyway if the cap fits as they
say, wear it!
The West is defined by itself, by its materialistic and consumer
culture. You'd have to be blind or stupid or maybe both to deny it! If
you want to see how the West defines itself, read the magazines, and
watch the movies! I'm sure you do anyway. There you have it!
Let's take a few of your own examples to see how silly your comments really are:
How about this by the Beatles:
The best things in life are free
But you can keep 'em for the birds and bees
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want
Your lovin' give me a thrill
But your lovin' don't pay my bills
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, oh yeah
That's what I want
Money don't get everything, it's true
What it don't get, I can't use
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want
Money don't get everything, it's true
What it don't get, I can't use
Now give me money, that's what I want
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want
Now give me money
A lot of money
I wanna be free
Oh, outta my head
That's what I want, oh yeah
Now give me money
A lot of money
Oh yeah, I need money
Oh now give me money
That's what I want, yeah
That's what I want!
Hey, and I really couldn't be bothered to go through the rest of
Alicia Keys songs, but I don't even need to because "If I ain't Got
You (Alicia Keys)" which you claim "completely rejects materialism"
doesn't at all! In fact this song so perfectly proves my point that
you Benjamin are so affected by the materialistic ideas of the West
that you think passionate love and devotion to another human being
(which the song is so obviously about) is not materialistic, but if
you actaully tried to understand my lecture you'd have realised its
all about how we are deluded by this world, and its glitter and we
have lost our connection with Allah, the Almighty, and it is only in
knowing Him that we will find true peace. We look for happiness in the
things of this world, whereas trying to find happiness in the things
of this world is real cause of our misery and misguidance.
Sure there are people with morals, a deep commitment to justice, even
ascetics, peace activist, environmentalists, real practising
Christians, and indeed Muslims who consider themselves part of the
West, as in fact I do, who do not conform to the hedonistic culture,
and do not consider mere material gratification the means to happiness
and success. There are of course parts of Western culture also that
run counter to the general ethos that prevails (although I would argue
that this is due to tattered remnants of Divine Guidance that is still
remaining. I will go as far as to in some respect (and I have talked
about this in many other lectures) where the West is in fact committed
to superior moral values that those that can be found in the Muslim
world at this time. However, I would argue that hedonism and
materialism fundamentally defines the West today and it is how most
western people define themselves in their attitudes and practices.
When I say most, I mean by far the greatest number. So although it is
a generalization, it is justified.
You get even more confusing in your critique when you imply that my
specific examples of certain sexual acts are intended to be generally
true! The only one being plainly dishonest here is you!
Did I read you were an English teacher? Oh dear! I'm very worried for
the students at Al Azhar.
You highlight that the critics of following one's desires are many,
but this in fact proves my point, since they, like me have acknowledge
the hedonistic individualism of modern Western culture! My comments
about the Consumer Society and Capitalism specifically can be found
being made by many Westerners! Try reading Marx for starters :) The
Shock Doctrine, by Naomi Klein. If you have any doubts about the evils
of capitalism as promoted mostly by the USA watch this documentary
called "The Corporation" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pin8fbdGV9Y
The funny thing about your critique is that it guilty of what it
accuses of i.e. generalizations, and a failure to understand, mixing
truth and falsehood.
Interestingly while you yourself talk about generalizations you make a
massive generalization about me when you call me primarily and
entertainer, not a scholar. I wonder how many of my lectures you have
listened to or articles you have read to make such a generalization,
which I find in fact quite insulting.
Please watch this set of lectures: The Proof that Islam is the Truth
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOwA0v026wY
or for something more scholarly read this:
http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/uncomfortable_questions__an_authoritative_exposition__by__abdur_raheem_green_
I am primary in fact a teacher and educator. What I spend a lot of
time and effort doing is taking complex concepts and ideas and
transforming them into simple concepts that people can relate to and
understand... and guess what that involves doing a lot of the time? It
involves making generalizations. Yes, of course it's not 100%
accurate, but is not 100% accurate when our science teachers explain
the model of the atom with reference to the solar system. No, but
that's how we manage to understand complex models, by connecting them
to simpler ones that people understand.
Perhaps some nuclear physicist would belittle this teachers efforts,
and even call it "entertainment." Most of us would say that this
physicist needs to get a life!
We humans always speak and talk in generalizations, as does God in His
last and final message, the Quran, as do Christian, Hindu, Buddhist
and Jewish scriptures.
Let's take the beatitudes from the Gospels for example:
"Blessed are the mourners for they shall be comforted"
Well has EVERY mourner been comforted. Millions haven't! So this a
generalization, and so Jesus is wrong using your approach.
and how about...
"Blessed are the peace makers they shall be called sons of God."
Well I never heard Gandhi being called that! Actually not even mother
Teresa. In fact it leaves out women altogether since they must surely
be daughters not sons. Can't be right then!.
Let's take another generalization from Jesus:
"Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye devour
widows' houses, and for a pretence make long prayer: therefore ye
shall receive the greater damnation. (Matthew 23:14)”
So Jesus just called every Pharisee and Scribe hypocrites! That's a
massive generalization. Talk about preaching hate!
It is blindingly obvious that a generalization does not include
everyone, and when one is being made (a generalization that is) it
doesn't mean to include everyone.
What becomes increasingly entertaining in your comments is how you go
on to offer yourself as an American who is not like my description.
It reminds me of a friend of mine who insisted that smoking couldn't
be bad because his grandfather smoked twenty a day and lived healthily
until he was eighty!
Another important point is context, and to be fair there is no way for
you to know this.
My lecture was never aimed at, nor did I expect it to be listened to
by students in Al Azhar who might interpret this as an anti Western
hate tirade (and I really doubt they do anyway). It was aimed a group
of Muslims living in Australia trying to hang on to some remnants of
their religion in the consumer society. Although I think the lessons
from my lecture ring true to many. If Muslims have lost their
connection with the true source of inner peace, which is remembrance
of Allah, it is in part because they are victims of it, not because,
as in the case with the West, because they are the propagators of it.
Now when your comments become comical, but sadly not amusing in the
least is when you suggest that my lecture is the sort of thing that
spreads misunderstanding and this hatred about America, and you equate
it with how Islam is misrepresented in the West. Of course you have
cleverly pre-empted the obvious thought that those who might bother to
read your comments will have, which is of course: "Well this
Abdurraheem is from the West, He is educated there and understands
Western society well!" And I'd like to confirm to your readers that
they are in fact entirely correct in this assumption. In fact it might
even interest them more that I had reached many of these conclusions
about the West and its economic system before I became Muslim!
Now the reason this is comical is because the analogy of comparing
misrepresentation of the USA with the misrepresentation of Islam is
false (any of you studying fiq will understand qiyas baatil) is
because Islam is a religion, philosophy and ideology. America and the
West are geographical locations. My critic is of the predominant
ideology of the West, consumerism and by extension capitalism, and the
hedonistic culture attached to it, not of America, the USA per-say.
The real image problem for America is not because of people like me
saying what I do, but more likely because of America's unflinching and
almost blind support for Israel, it's illegal invasion of Muslim
lands, causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Muslim
civilians, it's continued financial and military support for despotic
dictators through out the world, including the Muslim world.
You say that you want to lern, but if that is the case you need to
listen. How many though have ears that hear, but they are deaf, and
how many have eyes that can see but they are blind, and how many
tongues that speak and fingers that type, but they might as well be
dumb!
As for you final story, well there's a really nice thing that can be
found in the gospels the Jesus is supposed to have said:
"Take the log out your own eye, before you take the twig out of others!"
The story my friend applies most to you!
Hi Mohamed,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I agree that the US assistance to Egypt comes as part of the Egypt-Israel peace treaty. You say that 'the US has an interest in providing this assistance as a sponsor of the treaty.' What do you think this 'interest' is exactly? In 2008, the US gave $1.49 billion ($201 million in economic aid or USAID that Scobey is talking about, and 1.29 billion in military aid) to Egypt. US gave Israel $2.43 billion ($44 million in economic aid and $2.38 billion in military aid). So Egypt got almost 4 times the economic aid that Israel did. Can check all US foreign aid here. You wrote that Egyptians hate hearing "we did so and so for you." I think you may be right about many Egyptians' reaction but does that mean that she should not explain what really happened with the assistance? Do you think that the Egyptians reacting that way have carefully looked at where USAID money really went? Or do you think their reaction has some assumptions that may not be accurate? I think larger grievances like the US govt's role in Israel-Palestine and Iraq sometimes colors Egyptians' perceptions about all US govt programs, as if the US is one monolithic entity. The US govt is large and has many different faces. If the US govt waged an unjust war in Iraq and supports a murderous Israeli govt/military, does this mean that the US providing scholarships to Egyptian scientists is somehow unjust as well? I personally agree with Scobey that USAID does a lot of good work-good work that is not erased by other actions of other faces of the US govt or military.
Also, should Scobey let people's negative reaction stop her from defending programs she believes in? What advice would you have given ambassador Scobey before writing her letter? If you were the US ambassador to Egypt and you were accused of using aid as a tool to interfere in Egypt's affairs what would you have done after reading the Al Akhbar article? If I were ambassador I would carefully examine the record of what exactly USAID had actually given money to in Egypt and reflect on whether or not the author of the article was right or not about the aid being interference. Do you believe that the items on Scobey's list really were accomplished? If so, which of them do you think constituted interference in Egyptian affairs?
You wrote Egyptians 'are not going to be slaves for this 30 year favor.' In what ways were Egyptians slaves of the US for the last 30 years? I think the US's primary concern was no Egypt-Israeli war.
I think it is important to distinguish, Scobey is not talking about military aid, only about economic aid. You said Egyptians 'are totally aware that this achieves US interests before achieving theirs.'
The projects Scobey lists advance education, public health, energy etc. for Egyptians. How, for example, does expanding 20 million Egyptians' access to clean drinking water serve US interests more than Egyptians' interests?
About US congress setting conditions on assistance, if you were in charge of this money would you not set any conditions? What if you gave billions and Mubarak just put all the money into his private account in Switzerland? Or if he used it to expand the police force and do nothing for ordinary Egyptians? And of course, if Egypt does not accept the conditions Egypt does not have to accept the money. Do you consider the ELRC to be "interfering" in Egyptian affairs? Which of the projects on Scobey's list is "interference"?
Mubarak accused the US if interfering in Egyptian affairs hundreds of times whenever the US pushed for something that was not in Mubarak's interest. Do you think these accusations helped or hurt Mubaraks' popularity with the people?
Have you noticed that every Arab dictator (including Mubarak) besieged by protests blames "foreign interference" as the reason behind the protests? Why do you think this is?
Finally you said 'this way of speaking...needs to be changed if the US wants to keep the Egyptian people as a friend'. How do you think should it be changed?
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I agree that the US assistance to Egypt comes as part of the Egypt-Israel peace treaty. You say that 'the US has an interest in providing this assistance as a sponsor of the treaty.' What do you think this 'interest' is exactly? In 2008, the US gave $1.49 billion ($201 million in economic aid or USAID that Scobey is talking about, and 1.29 billion in military aid) to Egypt. US gave Israel $2.43 billion ($44 million in economic aid and $2.38 billion in military aid). So Egypt got almost 4 times the economic aid that Israel did. Can check all US foreign aid here. You wrote that Egyptians hate hearing "we did so and so for you." I think you may be right about many Egyptians' reaction but does that mean that she should not explain what really happened with the assistance? Do you think that the Egyptians reacting that way have carefully looked at where USAID money really went? Or do you think their reaction has some assumptions that may not be accurate? I think larger grievances like the US govt's role in Israel-Palestine and Iraq sometimes colors Egyptians' perceptions about all US govt programs, as if the US is one monolithic entity. The US govt is large and has many different faces. If the US govt waged an unjust war in Iraq and supports a murderous Israeli govt/military, does this mean that the US providing scholarships to Egyptian scientists is somehow unjust as well? I personally agree with Scobey that USAID does a lot of good work-good work that is not erased by other actions of other faces of the US govt or military.
Also, should Scobey let people's negative reaction stop her from defending programs she believes in? What advice would you have given ambassador Scobey before writing her letter? If you were the US ambassador to Egypt and you were accused of using aid as a tool to interfere in Egypt's affairs what would you have done after reading the Al Akhbar article? If I were ambassador I would carefully examine the record of what exactly USAID had actually given money to in Egypt and reflect on whether or not the author of the article was right or not about the aid being interference. Do you believe that the items on Scobey's list really were accomplished? If so, which of them do you think constituted interference in Egyptian affairs?
You wrote Egyptians 'are not going to be slaves for this 30 year favor.' In what ways were Egyptians slaves of the US for the last 30 years? I think the US's primary concern was no Egypt-Israeli war.
I think it is important to distinguish, Scobey is not talking about military aid, only about economic aid. You said Egyptians 'are totally aware that this achieves US interests before achieving theirs.'
The projects Scobey lists advance education, public health, energy etc. for Egyptians. How, for example, does expanding 20 million Egyptians' access to clean drinking water serve US interests more than Egyptians' interests?
About US congress setting conditions on assistance, if you were in charge of this money would you not set any conditions? What if you gave billions and Mubarak just put all the money into his private account in Switzerland? Or if he used it to expand the police force and do nothing for ordinary Egyptians? And of course, if Egypt does not accept the conditions Egypt does not have to accept the money. Do you consider the ELRC to be "interfering" in Egyptian affairs? Which of the projects on Scobey's list is "interference"?
Mubarak accused the US if interfering in Egyptian affairs hundreds of times whenever the US pushed for something that was not in Mubarak's interest. Do you think these accusations helped or hurt Mubaraks' popularity with the people?
Have you noticed that every Arab dictator (including Mubarak) besieged by protests blames "foreign interference" as the reason behind the protests? Why do you think this is?
Finally you said 'this way of speaking...needs to be changed if the US wants to keep the Egyptian people as a friend'. How do you think should it be changed?
How to Get Internet in your home in Egypt
If you must have internet immediately, you can opt for a USB modem. USB modems can be purchased in any Etisalat or Vodafone or Mobinil store and generally cost 100LE Egyptian Pounds (under $20) for the device and then you can buy prepaid cards (20, 50, 100LE) and recharge periodically or you can choose a monthly service plan. For around 150LE/month you can get unlimited minutes but the connection works on the 3G cellphone network (like a Blackberry or Iphone) so speed is similar to dial-up. Just plug the USB modem into a USB port on your computer, install the software (go to My Computer and double-click on the icon if it does not install automatically) and you should be surfing in 5 minutes. If your computer does not have problems recognizing the device, the network is generally reliable but may be down for short periods (minutes not hours) once in a while.
Getting high-speed home DSL is a whole nother ball game.
You will need to:
1. Figure out your landline number
2. Go the your nearest Egypt Telecom office. Tell them your landline number and pay any balance on the line. Get a receipt from Egypt Telecom showing that your landline account is paid in full.
3. Get a copy of your apartment lease from your landlord.
4. Take your Egypt Telecom receipt, your apartment lease and your passport to an ISP office (Etisalat and TE Data are the biggest but Noor has better customer service and quicker installation for the same price and speed). Unlimited 512 Kbps-speed ADSL connection usually is 100LE/month, 1 MB-speed 140LE/month and 2 MB-speed 240LE/month.
You will need a router (which you'll probably be offered when you set up your connection) and once your DSL line is on you will need to call your ISP to configure your router (they have ISP-provided passwords). If you are told by an ISP that it will take more than 2 weeks to install your line or there is a long delay for any other reason tell the employee that you will shop around, Vodafone, Link and Mobinil all offer residential DSL. And if you seem to be getting very bad customer service or have major problems getting connected, the only way I was able to get effective service was to ask threaten to close my account, they sent a technician to my home the next day, solved the problem and I have been online since.
If you decide to tackle the DSL option, expect difficulties, be patient and try to smile and take a deep breath if you get frustrated, eventually your DSL will work if you have the determination to stick with it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

