Hello Abdur Raheem Greene,
Thank you for your response.
First of all I want to apologize for being disrespectful to you in my response to your video. That was not my intention and resulted only from my carelessness. I see no benefit in engaging in a war of words with you. I apologize if my writing was in any way a source of agitation to you. If you interpreted my comments as personal attacks on you, I want to emphasize that I take issue only with your ideas, I strive only for truth, not to "win" an argument. My goals in writing a response to your video were only to deepen awareness and stimulate a critical analysis of your arguments among students at our language center, insofar as I instead generated hostility on your part, my response clearly failed and I take responsibility for that.
In this response I will try to be more mindful and careful with my words and I hope I can stay completely respectful. I will also do my best to avoid being defensive.
I completely agree that there are many Western songs, movies, magazines etc. that glorify materialism (rap music has some of the most extreme examples), just as there are many that reject it, and I'd say movies and magazines are a pretty narrow view of a culture.
Your point that I liked the most was that passionate love and devotion to another human being is materialistic. That we are deluded by this world and its glitter. It sounds almost Buddhist to me and I can appreciate the perspective in it and its capacity for deepening inner peace. Are you Sufi? I personally believe passionate love and devotion to another human being is only deluding if we cling to its image and make that image our master in our desire for permanence. Maybe this is why you included the word "passion" because that seems to make it a thing. But, in my view, love itself is part of life and being human and can be honest and pure without corrupting us but we must be careful and mindful.
You asserted that hedonism and materialism fundamentally define the West and Westerners' attitudes and practices. I don't necessarily disagree with this point, only with the oversimplification and reductionism of "fundamentally defining" a culture as vast and diverse as the West.
About the example of specific sexual acts and "another man's wife" being generally true. I included this point because many of my Azhar students have told me that they think wife-swapping and orgies are normal and common in America, so my point is only that your words may have an affect you did not intend that I thought you might want to be aware of.
I agree with your point of taking a complex idea and framing it in a way that makes it easier for masses to understand but I disagree with your blanket defense of generalizations and though, as you pointed out, I sometimes fall into generalizations myself, that is a result of my lack of diligence and I think a responsibility of being a teacher or educator is being diligent and precise. Do you see any problem with anti-Muslim Americans making generalizations about Muslims? Perhaps you consider this quibbling or an overly academic point but I urge you to reconsider, I think these details in the way we talk have a profound impact. And you said that it is "blindingly obvious" that generalizations are not true 100%, part of my purpose in writing you was to explain the way some of my students interpreted your words in ways you probably did not and could not have anticipated, in other words it was not obvious to them. I do understand you were making a speech to an Australian audience but with your speeches going to Youtube of course the potential audience is broader. I agree that Jesus (not sure if you guessed I was Christian, but I am not), etc. and other scriptures speak in generalizations, sometimes they are more axiomatic "blessed are the meek" and I see no problem with this and sometimes they are more analogous to the generalizations you made that summarily describe a diverse group. A big part of my job is trying to encourage students to think beyond stereotypes and be more analytical, this is why the generalizations are such an issue to me. I hope you can appreciate that my whole purpose is trying to build bridges of understanding between the Muslim and Western worlds, can you imagine how your lecture affects the pursuit of this goal?
I agree that political and military actions of the US govt Israel, Iraq, Afghanistan etc. are the main source of anti-Americanism. But I think the cultural stereotypes are also very important and have significant impact and can lead to dehumanizing the "other".
If my email has stimulated your thinking and added to your peace I have succeeded, if it has added agitation then I have failed and I apologize. I will check out the Corporation and I have read Marx and a bit of Naomi Klein. I plan to post your email to our blog, if you'd rather I didnt please let me know. Peace Ben |
No comments:
Post a Comment