Understanding the American Right

Hi Mohamed,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I agree that the US assistance to Egypt comes as part of the Egypt-Israel peace treaty. You say that 'the US has an interest in providing this assistance as a sponsor of the treaty.' What do you think this 'interest' is exactly? In 2008, the US gave $1.49 billion ($201 million in economic aid or USAID that Scobey is talking about, and 1.29 billion in military aid) to Egypt. US gave Israel $2.43 billion ($44 million in economic aid and $2.38 billion in military aid). So Egypt got almost 4 times the economic aid that Israel did. Can check all US foreign aid here. You wrote that Egyptians hate hearing "we did so and so for you." I think you may be right about many Egyptians' reaction but does that mean that she should not explain what really happened with the assistance? Do you think that the Egyptians reacting that way have carefully looked at where USAID money really went? Or do you think their reaction has some assumptions that may not be accurate? I think larger grievances like the US govt's role in Israel-Palestine and Iraq sometimes colors Egyptians' perceptions about all US govt programs, as if the US is one monolithic entity.  The US govt is large and has many different faces. If the US govt waged an unjust war in Iraq and supports a murderous Israeli govt/military, does this mean that the US providing scholarships to Egyptian scientists is somehow unjust as well?  I personally agree with Scobey that USAID does a lot of good work-good work that is not erased by other actions of other faces of the US govt or military.
Also, should Scobey let people's negative reaction stop her from defending programs she believes in? What advice would you have given ambassador Scobey before writing her letter? If you were the US ambassador to Egypt and you were accused of using aid as a tool to interfere in Egypt's affairs what would you have done after reading the Al Akhbar article? If I were ambassador I would carefully examine the record of what exactly USAID had actually given money to in Egypt and reflect on whether or not the author of the article was right or not about the aid being interference. Do you believe that the items on Scobey's list really were accomplished? If so, which of them do you think constituted interference in Egyptian affairs?
You wrote Egyptians 'are not going to be slaves for this 30 year favor.' In what ways were Egyptians slaves of the US for the last 30 years? I think the US's primary concern was no Egypt-Israeli war.
I think it is important to distinguish, Scobey is not talking about military aid, only about economic aid. You said Egyptians 'are totally aware that this achieves US interests before achieving theirs.'
The projects Scobey lists advance education, public health, energy etc. for Egyptians. How, for example, does expanding 20 million Egyptians' access to clean drinking water serve US interests more than Egyptians' interests?
About US congress setting conditions on assistance, if you were in charge of this money would you not set any conditions? What if you gave billions and Mubarak just put all the money into his private account in Switzerland? Or if he used it to expand the police force and do nothing for ordinary Egyptians?  And of course, if Egypt does not accept the conditions Egypt does not have to accept the money. Do you consider the ELRC to be "interfering" in Egyptian affairs? Which of the projects on Scobey's list is "interference"?
Mubarak accused the US if interfering in Egyptian affairs hundreds of times whenever the US pushed for something that was not in Mubarak's interest. Do you think these accusations helped or hurt Mubaraks' popularity with the people?
Have you noticed that every Arab dictator (including Mubarak) besieged by protests blames "foreign interference" as the reason behind the protests? Why do you think this is?
Finally you said 'this way of speaking...needs to be changed if the US wants to keep the Egyptian people as a friend'. How do you think should it be changed?

No comments: