Understanding the American Right

Thank you Mohamed for your Comments,

You asked why the right to free speech stops when it comes to the holocaust.  Why do you think this? Where did you get this idea? In the USA, free speech applies equally to "holocaust denial" (or "revisionism" of the history of the holocaust) as it does to any other topics. What special laws are you referring to? Holocaust denial is explicitly or implicitly illegal in 16 countries: Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Hungary, Israel, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, and Switzerland but it is legal in the USA (you can find more details about: laws related to holocaust/"anti-semitic" speech here).  The argument in the countries' legislatures where holocaust denial is illegal is generally that such speech is "incitement to ethnic/racial hatred or violence," basically this limit to free speech is the same in the USA but only "incitement to ethnic/racial violence" not merely hatred is outlawed. Free speech is not absolute, it does have limits in the USA and elsewhere in the West. If free speech conflicts with public safety or incites violence or killing then free speech is subjugated, public safety is more important according to the law. Again, free speech is not absolute. For example, I cannot publicly advocate the assassination of President Obama because this is a direct incitement to violence, so this speech is not free and is punishable by US law, nor can I yell "fire" in a crowded theater because it directly incites panic and probably running which endangers people's safety. So the deciding factor legally in the USA is whether or not physical harm to anyone can be directly attributed to (or reasonably be believed to cause physical harm or violence) a speech act. If physical harm to anyone is likely to result from the speech then the speech is not protected by the US bill of rights, so again the topic of the speech does not matter only the likelihood of it leading to violence.
Of course, determining what speech acts "directly engender violence or are a threat to public safety" involves a lot of interpretation and room for discretion by judges. It is a very controversial issue in the USA and is debated vigorously in law schools, the media, etc. If you want to better understand US law about free speech related to "hate speech" the most famous Supreme Court case was Skokie vs. Illinois and it was about whether it was legal for an American neo-Nazi group to gather and march in the town of Skokie, Illinois where many holocaust survivors lived, you can read more here.
If you doubt that freedom of speech in denying the holocaust is really protected in the USA, here is some evidence. I was a student at Columbia University in New York City in 2007 when Mahmoud Ahmedinejad came to the university and spoke. He freely questioned the holocaust publicly at a major American university. You can watch here:










Before Ahmedinejad's speech, Jewish student groups At Columbia University and others vigorously protested Ahmedinejad being allowed to speak but in the end free speech was protected and Ahmedinejad was allowed to speak his mind freely even though what he was saying was offensive to many Jews and others. Free speech is sometimes offensive and it is still protected. A society of rights depends on the willingness of citizens to accept this idea: "I will uphold others' rights to speak freely even if their speech is offensive to me in exchange they will uphold my rights to speak freely even when it is offensive to them" This reciprocity is the essence of free speech, and any society in which the masses of people do not accept and embrace this idea will have a very difficult time with free speech and government will inevitably end up restricting free speech. The most famous quote about the Western idea of free speech is "I disagree with what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it." Do you see any wisdom in this idea?
The only law in the American system, that I know of, that specifically targets speech issues related to the holocaust and anti-semitism is a George W. Bush-created program in 2004 that reviews other countries in the world for their records of what is judged by the program to be "anti-semitic speech." All it does is track information on what it deems anti-semitism (something that the State Dept. had already done for years), but the US government has no international authority to legally punish any countries where there is a lot of anti-semitism. Essentially, I think it is a relatively meaningless law that Bush approved for political reasons, Bush wanted Jews in Florida to support him and vote for him in the 2004 election. This US law was first proposed by the only surviving member of a concentration camp that is currently alive and serving in the US congress (House of Representatives) and it does not restrict free speech related to the holocaust in any way in the USA.
For those who doubt whether the holocaust concentration camps and systematic genocide of Jews in Europe really happened, I encourage you to watch the video below, it might change your thinking. Warning, it contains very graphic images.

You wrote that it is "too painful to see the Quran burnt." I understand how painful this must be for a Muslim, and I think your example of asking a non-Muslim how they would feel if someone burnt their mother or father's picture, just to mock him, is an appropriate analogy and helps non-Muslims better understand. Also, for Americans, perhaps even more sensitive are racial offenses, if a US senator from Maryland, for example, said "there are too many niggers in Baltimore and we should force them all to move out" the offense would be so great that there would be a violent reaction in the streets. So Americans can become emotionally reactive and violent too, just probably about different things like race more so than religion. I do not believe such reactions are justified.
To be honest, if someone burnt the picture of my mother or father just to mock him or her I would probably naturally feel very personally offended. I would be angry and maybe want to retaliate and maybe even want to violently attack the person. This is human. This is understandable. However, at the same time as I was feeling my anger well up inside of me I would try to calm down and to tell myself to practice self-control. We all have natural reactions and emotions but I believe in trying to control these reactions.
I do not believe that initiating violence (unless it is to defend yourself or others from violence or harm) is ever justified. I have a commitment to myself to not become violent even when I am angry and want to become violent. So I stop myself even though part of me wants to react.
Essentially this reaction to being offended is about PRIDE.
In my understanding of Islam and Arab history, in Arabia before Islam, a man's honor and pride were extremely important. When offended, men often became violent to defend their honor, their wife's honor or the honor of their tribe. Pride was very important in Arabian and Bedouin culture and if a man ignored something offensive he was viewed as a coward and not respected in the community. I believe this same cultural characteristic is at the root of the sometimes violent reaction to offense to Islam today. what do you think?  I believe this tremendous pride is considered to be Jahilliyah, part of the pre-Islamic culture of Arabia. In my understanding the teachings of Islam emphasize the importance of Taqwa and Hilm. I understand Taqwa as mindfulness of God, I believe this is the same thing I was talking about when I explained that I would try to stop my own reactions when offended and control myself rather than simply giving in to my emotional, human reaction. In this sense Taqwa gives us a mental tool to remember mindfulness and God which gives us strength to better practice self-control, forebearance or hilm the opposite of jahilliyah.
I have believed in the wisdom of stopping and controlling one's own reactions for a long time (though I just recently learned that it is called Taqwa in Arabic after living in Egypt). So I do not value the pre-Islamic Bedouin/Arabic ideal that said that if a man is offended by another man and does not retaliate then he is weak and cowardly. I believe not retaliating and controlling one's self actually takes greater strength and I believe the ideas of Taqwa and Hilm can remind us of this.
I have heard many stories of the prophet Muhammad being offended. For example, students have told me that a neighbor threw garbage on the prophet and insulted him many times and the prophet did not become angry but rather remained friendly to the offensive man. This does not sound like pride, it sounds like something else. Then one day the man was not out on the streets to insult the prophet because he was sick in bed and the prophet went to visit him and show compassion. The man was so amazed that the prophet still showed love to him even though he had insulted him so much that he converted to Islam. To me this demonstrated tremendous Taqwa and Hilm this is what makes it such a powerful story, he was guided by something greater than pride. I understand Hilm as forebearance, patience and self-control the opposite of rage and emotional outbursts like what happened recently in Afghanistan. So in my understanding taqwa helps us to practice hilm, I believe remembering and meditating on these two wise concepts has the power to  help free Muslims from the anger, indignation and sense of hurt that comes when Islam is offended (another famous example was the offensive Danish newspaper cartoons of the prophet Muhammad).
Another way to think of it it is like this. Going back to your example of someone being offensive or mocking my mother or father. Another thing I would think of if someone burnt a picture of my mother or father is that that person must have serious psychological problems. There must be a root to that person's anger. If the person mocking my parents does not know me or my parents personally then I will be even more certain that the person has psychological problems (like Terry Jones does not really know Islam).
I ask you, if the man burning the Quran was judged to be clinically insane by a doctor, would this change how offended you felt? Imagine if the person was mentally disabled and had a brain disease that enlarged the part of his brain that controls anger and that he had become more and more angry as the disease got worse. Would you still be deeply offended by this man's burning the Quran? I suspect that if the man is truly crazy then you will not be offended in the same way. This is very important. Why would you not be offended in the same way? I think it is at least partially because you realize that the man's action of burning the Quran is really about HIM, the man and his own problems and has little to nothing to do with you or even with Islam. I think that the situation with the pastor Terry Jones in Florida who burnt the Quran was just like this. Terry Jones is crazy and he has serious psychological problems. His burning the Quran is caused by his own problems. People who burn the Quran are simply troubled and crazy and should be ignored like people yelling from an insane asylum window.
If you are walking by an insane asylum and a man furiously yells at you "You are a pink elephant, you are a pink elephant." Would you be deeply offended by this? Clearly the man is crazy. Ignoring him and saying "wow he is crazy" is all you can do. If someone walking along the street and was called a pink elephant and got very angry and wanted to attack the crazy man yelling, what would you think of this person?
Another perspective is,
If you feel that honor dictates that you cannot ignore any offense to your religion then you are a slave to other people. Because if anyone offends Islam and you MUST respond to defend Islam then other people control you because they can offend Islam whenever they want and then watch as you predictably react every time. You become a slave to their choices. Imagine if Islam is offended one hundred times a day (in reality it is much more), if you are obligated to defend the honor of Islam you could spend your whole life defending the honor of Islam. Your whole life will be determined by those who do not respect you or your religion not by you. Instead imagine if you decide you will stop defending the honor of your religion and choose to take control of your own life and define your own identity (not as merely a reactionary but as an independent self-controlled individual) and become highly educated, improve your community, work honest and hard, help the weak, sick, old and lost people in your community, and raise a strong, compassionate family? This would be seizing your own life and I see more beauty and wisdom in this, choosing to define yourself, rather than letting others define you and being a slave to their actions/words.
If you are interested, here is more thoughts about dealing with anger (it says that absolutely no anger is righteous anger).
Are my understandings of hilm, taqwa and jahilliyah accurate? Do you agree with my points?

No comments: