Understanding the American Right

US Ambassador Scobey's Letter to Al Akhbar (Arabic and English)

Al Akhbar Article publishing Amb. Scobey’s letter to the Editor, April 17, 2011:
Headline: “USAID has contributed to Egyptian development projects for thirty years” The strength of a democracy depends on the strength of its civil society and
In the Mubarak era, this assistance was considered “interference”
 
Al Akhbar, April 17, 2001 Page 9.
cid:image001.jpg@01CBFCF4.B2946300
                                                              April 12, 2011
 
To The Editor:
I was surprised and disappointed to see the April 8 article by Abdel Qader Shuheib attacking the U.S. assistance program for Egypt.  Shuheib accuses the U.S. of using its assistance as a “tool” to “interfere in Egypt’s affairs.”  In reality, USAID has contributed to Egyptian development needs for more than thirty years, and U.S. taxpayers have over this time financed nearly $30 billion in assistance programs.  This $30 billion has been an investment in the people of Egypt and has generated far more than its face value in assisting Egyptians to build their own capacity and develop their own resources.  To identify but a very few of the many achievements, these programs have :
 Expanded access to clean drinking water and sanitation to more than 20 million Egyptians where no such service was previously available.
Contributed nearly $1 billion for public health resulting in significant extension of the lifespan of Egyptians and dramatic decreases in infant and child mortality.  In 1975, about 130 out of every 1000 infants died after childbirth; the number now is about 25 – a more than 500% improvement. 
Built more than 2,000 schools and stocked 39,000 school libraries.
Rehabilitated and refurbished important antiquity sites, such as Luxor's West Bank and the Bab Zweila in Cairo, helping to preserve Egypt’s great heritage for generations to come and to sustain Egypt’s tourism.
Since 2005, sent more than 2,200 Egyptians to the United States for university degrees and training programs.  Over the past 30 years we have also awarded 3000 Fulbright scholarships along with 2300 high school and university level scholarships through other programs.
Invested $1.8 billion in 13 electric power sector projects accounting directly and indirectly for roughly one third of total present capacity. 
From 1982 to 1995, USAID spent USD 140 million to rectify original design flaws and keep the Aswan Dam generating power at its full capacity.
Invested billions of dollars in technical and financial assistance to modernize Egypt’s economy to create new jobs in fields like high-technology and manufacturing.  This has directly contributed to the World Bank naming Egypt one of the top ten Doing Business locations in the world four out of the last five years.
Helped the poorest Egyptians improve their livelihoods by supporting well over a million Egyptians with the extension of 8.3 million micro-credit loans valued at about USD 2.5 billion. 
All of these projects were completed with the strictest standards of transparency and accountability of any assistance program in the world.  We are proud of this record, and we are proud of the patriotic Egyptians partners we worked with every step of the way.  And yes, the United States has always included in its assistance programs funding to strengthen and expand Egypt’s civil society, including those brave Egyptians struggling for democracy and human rights.  In the Mubarak era, this assistance was often labeled “interference,” and opposed by a government uncomfortable with hearing the voices of its own people.  I hope, after January 25, this line has changed.  The strength of a democracy depends on the strength of its civil society, its people, every bit as much as its government.               
                                                          Sincerely,   
 
                                                          Margaret Scobey
                                                          Ambassador

3 comments:

Mohamed Amira said...

We all know that this assistance comes as a part of the peace treaty signed between Egypt and Israel in 1979. The US has an interest in providing this assistance as a sponsor of the treaty. What should be mentioned here also is that although Israel is about 15 times smaller than Egypt in population, it recieves as twice as what Egypt recieves, if not more.
I understand the it's a part of the Ambassodor's job to comment on news like that which touches the US policy. But I think Scobey does not know that Egyptians hate this way of speaking. Even if this assistance helped achieve a lot of developments, we don't like to hear we did so and so for you. This does not mean that Egyptians are ungrateful, but they are not going to be slaves for this 30-year favor. They would rather say: stop it-we don't care. They are totally aware that this achievs the US interests before achieving theirs.
Meanwhile, I think that Al-Akhbar reporter has a point. We always here about US congressional discussions about if Egypt does not do so and so, the assistance will be cut. It is obvious that the assistance is sometimes used as a tool to interfer in the Egyptian affairs. But honestly, this way of speaking and taking decsions concerning the assistance needs to be changed if the US wants to keep the Egyptian people as a friend. Otherwise, stop the assistance.

Benjamin Kalt said...

Hi Mohamed,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. You can read my response here.

Mohamed Amira said...

Thank you Ben for giving me the opportunity to clarify more. I believe that the US would not provide such assistance if there were not an interest for her and I understand that. The interest here is keeping Egypt as an ally and committed to the peace treaty to keep it away from troubling the US best ally on earth, Israel. My point from mentioning that Israel is also receiving assistance was to explain that this assistance is connected to a treaty that includes Israel too. Now the distribution of economic assistance might be reasonable. But the connected question is why the military aid given to Israel is as twice as that given to Egypt, given that Israel always receives the state-of-the-art weapons while Egypt never does. I can answer that. This is to insure Israel’s superiority over Egypt and the other “terrorist” Arab states in the region because again Israel is the US best ally on earth.
Concerning what happened to the assistance, I did not make doubts about where this assistance went; because I am sure they went where they should go. My point was about threatening to cut the assistance if you don’t do what you are asked to do. I know that such threats were basically directed to the Egyptian government that the Egyptian people did not choose. But somehow we feel always that this touches Egypt as a whole.
Maybe the Congress or whoever threatens to cut the assistance could speak separately to the Egyptian people and tell them “we are sorry to do that but your government is a dictatorship and we have to make sure that our money does not go to Mubarak’s pocket". But this would not happen. Because simply, although Mubarak was undoubtedly a dictator, it was also one of the best allies for the US and Israel which was of course a major interest for both the US and Israel to have Egypt as an ally.
Yes I agree that the US primary concern was no Egyptian-Israeli war; but that for the sake of Israel not for the sake of Egypt.
You said that other things like Iraq invasion and supporting Israel might affect the Egyptian perception of the USAID and sending the Egyptian scientists to the US. I believe this is natural and you cannot tell people to forget about the invasion and murdering the Palestinians and only remember the aid and the free scholarships because this is not going to happen. I don’t think we can make a judgment about someone from only one situation if you have the chance to judge on more.
I personally appreciate the time I spent in the US that was completely covered by Fulbright; but I believe I also had a job to do. It was mutual interest. I go and stay but I need to teach and give presentations and then when come back say what I witnessed which I was glad to do because it was consistent with my beliefs of enhancing mutual understanding.
I said I understand that this is Scobey’s job to respond but this how we are going to feel and this is not something that can be easily fixed.
I like making friendship more than starting confrontations. But sometimes it is not up to us. I hope what I wrote makes sense.