By Nayrouz Talaat - The Egyptian Gazette Tuesday, July 19, 2011 03:04:50 PM CAIRO - When a friend recently told me that Professor Jonathan Brown was visiting Cairo, I was determined to arrange an interview. My aim was to learn from the experiences of an American citizen-cum-Islamic researcher. | |
| Professor Jonathan Brown | |
It is high time to learn from Western scholars like Jonathan Brown about the political turning points in Egypt and the Middle East. Could you tell me a little about your background? I was raised in Washington DC but went to a boarding school called Thacher in California. I then attended Georgetown University [in Washington DC] and majored in History, with Russian as my second subject. Then I studied Arabic at the American University in Cairo from 2000 to 2001. I did the CASA [Centre for Arabic Study Abroad] programme. I also had lessons at Al-Azhar, mainly from Sheikh Ali Gomma. At the University of Chicago, I did my PhD in Near Eastern Languages and Civilisations and specialised in Islamic Thought. I graduated in 2006 with my dissertation on ‘The Canonisation of al-Bukhari and Muslim’. Is Islam your original religion or did you convert to Islam for certain reasons? I was not born into a Muslim family and I raised as an Episcopalian Protestant. This was mostly cultural �" religion was not part of our home. We did go to church on Sunday, however. At high school, I thought a lot about mortality, and in retrospect I was clearly longing for a sense of meaning. I always believed in God, but did not know how to express my belief. When I went to university I took a class on Islam and started reading the biography of the famous Austrian Muslim Muhammad Asad [The Road to Mecca]. I can’t remember, the details are fuzzy now, but at some point I felt that Islam was the religion in which I had always believed in my younger years. At the age of 19, I gradually started practising Islam. How long have you spent in Egypt? This is certainly not my first visit. I have been coming here almost every year for at least a month since 2000. I consider this country my second home, if it will accept me! My impression after the revolution is that there is pride in unseating a corrupt despot, but also a great deal of anxiety over the present economic conditions and real political reform. Mature voices at all levels understand that the process of moving the country out of the Mubarak era will take time. Others are understandably very worried about the present economic downturn, which stems from factors like the sudden decrease in tourism, and just want things to return to some form of normality. But looming over all this is the concern of the politically aware that the old regime could return in a new guise and the revolution would have been in vain. Of course, strong and effective leadership is needed to avoid this, as well as patience and fortitude on behalf of the people. Egyptian people understand this, I think. What do you think of the Islamists’ political role in Egypt? Will they win the elections and how will Western countries react? I think that all Islamist parties have accepted the fact that the Egyptian State will be a civil state that draws its core constitutional and legislative principles from the Sharia [Islamic Law]. That’s actually how the country is already constitutionally structured. I do not think life in Egypt will dramatically change if the president or ruling party are self-proclaimed ‘Islamists’. Egypt is already a very Islamic society: no-one drinks in the street, people dress conservatively, even the financial system has to justify its operations in terms of Islam. No-one is going to implement hudud [Islamic rules] haphazardly any time soon. The reaction of Western countries is much harder to predict. I think that, unlike in the case of Iran, which has become a pariah state in Western eyes, an Islamist-ruled Egypt would remain an important and accepted player in world politics. The country is too important to write off and this is not 1979. The ‘Islamic threat’ so often touted by Western pundits has been undermined by factors like AK Party rule in Turkey, and it will be less frightening when people see that Egypt is not much different from before. Why did you decide to do your Masters’ degree on Sahih al-Bukhari? My dissertation and first book were about how the Sahihayn achieved preeminence in Sunni Islam and their function in the Islamic civilisation, and how their position was challenged. This is obviously too much for one interview, but I can summarise the most important findings as follows. Criticising the Sahihayn, and whether they were allowed or not, was not really an issue until the 1700s. Before then, Muslim scholars advanced minor critiques of the two books (the Sahihayn) with no real reaction. Since the 1700s and until today, however, criticising the two books has become very contentious and controversial, because the books have become symbols of the tradition of Sunni learning. Groups like the Salafist revivalists, emerging in the 1700s, and Islamic modernists who criticised the two books [the first group because they believed no book was perfect except the Holy Qur’an and insisted on that, the second group because they considered the two books to exemplify many supposedly backward ideas of medieval Islam], threatened the historical continuity of the Sunni tradition. Defenders of that tradition therefore chose to raise the Sahihayn as a symbol of the authority of Sunni religious heritage. The two books became a representation of ideas contended over by various factions within Islamic thought in the early modern and modern periods. So, in short, debates over the Sahihayn were really about what the books stood for and not about the books themselves. Do you think Al-Azhar is playing a crucial role in spreading the right image of Islam all over the world? I think Al-Azhar has some of the best Muslim scholars in the world today, and they have done an admirable job in helping Muslims understand their religion better. Al-Azhar has of course faced many challenges since 1960, particularly since it was co-opted by the State during the Mubarak years. It will have to demonstrate its independence. What should the Islamic countries do to deliver the right image? Muslims should make sure their behavior, both as individuals in daily life and as a community of nations, truly reflects the teachings of Islam. Are you able to preach with total freedom in the US? And how do you deal with Islamophobia? In general, Americans enjoy constitutional protection to practise their religion. Muslims in America wear the hijab freely wherever they want. They can start their own schools, open mosques, pray at work and university and take time off to attend religious services like Friday prayers. There are two Muslim members of Congress. However, since the 1990s, there has been an increasingly powerful lobbying effort by individuals and organisations that hate Islam virulently, like Steven Emerson, and even members of Congress like Peter King and former Senator [now presidential candidate] Rick Santorum, to convince Americans that any Muslim that practises his or her religion is a secret extremist bent on destroying America. The chief culprit, they say, is the Muslim Brotherhood, which they consider a terrorist organisation. This has led to two states in the US, Tennessee and Oklahoma, passing laws banning the Sharia. Any Muslim who follows the Sharia in those states [which could mean anything from praying to paying zakat] can be charged with a crime. This gives prosecutors in these two states the right, potentially, to investigate, charge and convict any Muslim they want. In addition, the US Federal Government has used the broad reaching powers granted by the Patriot Act Laws [passed after 11/9, 2001] to prosecute a number of prominent Muslim charities. In the case of the Holy Land Foundation, the US Government sentenced the heads of this Muslim charity to 65 years in prison for sending money to zakat committees in the Palestinian territories. Although the US prosecutors admitted that none of this money was used for any violent ends, and that the zakat committees to which it was given were also given money by the US Government and the United Nations, these prosecutors argued that the Holy Land Foundation was nonetheless aiding Hamas, which the US Government has designated a terrorist organisation. In 2010, the United States Supreme Court declared that even speaking to a designated terrorist organisation, even if you tell them not to use violence, can be considered an act of material support for terrorism, for which you can be punished severely. You can see the effect of this legislation on Muslims in the US. It makes them feel alienated and targeted. Tell us more about the role of the centre you are working in. Do you think that the preaching centres in the US are correctly portraying Islam? I work as a professor in the Alwaleed bin Talal Centre for Muslim Christian Understanding, which is part of Georgetown University’s famous School of Foreign Service. Like other university departments, we are an academic centre, not a preaching centre. We offer university courses on subjects ranging from Islamic History to Islam & the West to Islamic Art. We also organise a range of academic and public outreach programmes designed to build bridges of understanding between the US and the Muslim world and improve academic discourse in the West on Islam and Muslims. For example, this year we are having a conference on Morality and Scripture in Islam and Judaism, as well as many educational workshops for American schoolteachers on Islam and Muslims, and a variety of interfaith academic forums. How did you in the US deal with the burning of the Qur'an? I think almost all educated Americans rejected the burning of the Qur’an and saw it for exactly what it was: the desperate, ignorant and bigoted act of a marginal preacher with few supporters who was trying to gain some sort of notoriety. The real problem is not the act of the man who burned the Qur’an, but the fact that the American media and public actually saw this as a subject that merited so much attention. This act would not have received any attention if the American public weren’t so obsessed with Islamophobia, which is mostly due to a small number of bigoted politicians and pseudo-scholars committed to vilifying Islam and Muslims at any price. Do you think that Arab Spring will change the Western attitude towards Islam? I think the Western countries will no longer have the luxury of dealing with handpicked dictators whose main concern was placating their Western sponsors. Western countries will have to deal with governments that will most likely represent the will of their people much more than before. That means an increased acknowledgment of the political, religious and cultural sensibilities and priorities of majority Muslim countries. | |
Links to Middle East, Latin-American and International Media, Blogs, Think Tanks, Universities and Advocacy Orgs (and a hodgepodge of vids)
Understanding the American Right
US Red Media
Egypt Military Moves to Cement a Muscular Role in Government

By DAVID D. KIRKPATRICK
Published: July 16, 2011
CAIRO — The military council governing Egypt is moving to lay down ground rules for a new constitution that would protect and potentially expand its own authority indefinitely, possibly circumscribing the power of future elected officials.
Related
Egypt Purges Mubarak-Era Police Officers (July 14, 2011)
Times Topic: Egypt News — Revolution and Aftermath
Moises Saman for The New York Times
Protesters unhappy with the military council have returned to Tahrir Square with increasing frequency to voice their demands.
The military announced Tuesday that it planned to adopt a “declaration of basic principles” to govern the drafting of a constitution, and liberals here initially welcomed the move as a concession to their demand for a Bill of Rights-style guarantee of civil liberties that would limit the potential repercussions of an Islamist victory at the polls.
But legal experts enlisted by the military to write the declaration say that it will spell out the armed forces’ role in the civilian government, potentially shielding the defense budget from public or parliamentary scrutiny and protecting the military’s vast economic interests. Proposals under consideration would give the military a broad mandate to intercede in Egyptian politics to protect national unity or the secular character of the state. A top general publicly suggested such a role, according to a report last month in the Egyptian newspaper Al- Masry Al- Youm. The military plans to adopt the document on its own, before any election, referendum or constitution sets up a civilian authority, said Mohamed Nour Farahat, a law professor working on the declaration. That would represent an about-face for a force that, after helping to oust President Hosni Mubarak five months ago, consistently pledged to turn over power to elected officials who would draft a constitution. Though the proposed declaration might protect liberals from an Islamist-dominated constitution, it could also limit democracy by shielding the military from full civilian control.
The military is long accustomed to virtual autonomy. Its budget has never been disclosed to Parliament, and its operations extend into commercial businesses like hotels, consumer electronics, bottled water and car manufacturing.
Some are already criticizing the military’s plans as a usurpation of the democratic process. Ibrahim Dawrish, an Egyptian legal scholar involved in devising a new Turkish constitution to reduce the political role of its armed forces, said the Egyptian military appeared to be emulating its Turkish counterpart. After a 1980 coup, the Turkish military assigned itself a broad role in politics as guarantor of the secular state, and in the process, contributed to years of political turbulence.
“The constitution can’t be monopolized by one institution,” he said. “It is Parliament that makes the constitution, not the other way around.”
Jurists involved in drafting the text say the Egyptian military told them to draw from several competing proposals that are circulating in Cairo. At least one assigns only a narrow, apolitical role to the military as guardian of national sovereignty. But others grant it sweeping authority and independence or a writ to intercede in civilian politics similar to the Turkish model.
Mr. Farahat said he was unsure of the wisdom of granting the armed forces a role in Egyptian politics, but he said he supported shielding the defense budget from public scrutiny as a guarantee of national security and military independence.
Others picked by the governing council to draft the declaration have argued publicly for a broad, Turkish-style role for the Egyptian armed forces in post-revolutionary politics. “The military in Egypt is unlike militaries in other countries where the military is isolated from the political life,” said Tahani el-Gebali, a judge involved in the drafting. “The military’s legacy gives it a special credibility, and hence it is only normal that the military will share some of the responsibility in protecting the constitutional legitimacy and the civil state.”
She said that she would prefer the governing council submit the declaration for up-or-down approval in a referendum, but that if it did not pass as expected, the document would derive its legitimacy from the authority of the governing military council.
The announcement of the declaration is a setback for the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group considered Egypt’s best-organized and most formidable political force. It was poised to win a major role in the new Parliament, and thus in the writing of the new constitution. The group has opposed liberal proposals to draft a constitution before parliamentary elections expected this fall or to postpone the elections long enough to let liberals catch up in organizing.
Liberals — most notably Mohamed ElBaradei, the former United Nations diplomat who is now running for president of Egypt — have advocated a code of agreed-upon universal rights as a compromise in the increasingly bitter debate between Islamists calling for an early election and liberals demanding a constitution first. Mr. ElBaradei, whose own proposal includes a provision that narrowly defines the military’s role guarding national security, said the declaration “really should be put to a referendum so it would have some legitimacy.”
That is especially relevant now, because the military council has come under mounting criticism for its opaque and inaccessible decision-making, occasionally heavy-handed tactics against civilian protesters, continued trials of civilians in military courts and intimidation of journalists who criticize it. Many have grown especially impatient with the pace of legal action against Mr. Mubarak and other former officials.
Related
Egypt Purges Mubarak-Era Police Officers (July 14, 2011)
Times Topic: Egypt News — Revolution and Aftermath
Demonstrators have returned to Tahrir Square with increasing frequency to voice their demands, culminating in a weeklong sit-in rivaling the days of the revolution. The military-led government, in turn, has appeared to respond to public demands with repeated concessions — including replacing an interim prime minister with the handpicked choice of the Tahrir protest leaders, arresting Mr. Mubarak and his two sons and releasing jailed activists. Last week, the government offered concessions, removing hundreds of senior police officers accused of killing protesters during the uprising. It also announced “the declaration of basic principles.”
This time, however, the demonstrators refused to budge. On Saturday afternoon, Gen. Tarek Mahdy, a member of the governing council, attempted to speak in Tahrir Square and was chanted off a stage, witnesses said. Many say they have grown increasingly cynical about the military. “They do comply with our demands, but within limits that they put on it themselves,” said Shady el-Ghazaly Harb, one of the organizers of the revolution.
The protests are increasingly taking aim at the military. On Thursday, a coalition of 24 political groups and five presidential contenders endorsed a call by the young leaders of the protests for the military to cede more power to a civilian government now rather than wait for elections.
The military leaders are sounding increasingly exasperated. In a news conference, Major General Mamdouh Shaheen, the council member who reportedly suggested a Turkish-style military role, recalled the military’s support for the revolution and its pivotal decision not to help uphold Mr. Mubarak.
The military would not give up “until there is an elected civil authority,” he said, but “the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces “does not want to stay in power.”
Egypt Delays Vote, Fires Police
Military Council Moves to Appease
Youth Activists Clamoring for Political Change
![[EGYPT]](http://si.wsj.net/public/resources/images/WO-AG268_EGYPT_G_20110713193817.jpg)
CAIRO—Egypt's interim government on Wednesday said it would delay parliamentary elections and fire police officers implicated in the deaths of protesters, the latest indication that the country's youth-led activists have substantial political weight five months after the president's fall.
With camped-out protesters extending Egypt's period of political instability, the interim military government opted Wednesday to delay elections until October or November from September, when they were scheduled to take place, said MENA, Egypt's state news agency.
In another nod to protesters, the ministry of interior announced the largest personnel shake-up in the institution's history—a move that would fire nearly 600 officers who had been accused of killing protesters during the country's 18-day uprising while rotating or transferring nearly 4,000 more.
While delaying elections wasn't an explicit demand of the demonstrators who continued to occupy Cairo's Tahrir Square for the sixth straight day Wednesday, both decisions show how Egypt's youthful revolutionaries are still able to mobilize huge crowds to profoundly shift the course of Egypt's democratic transition.
As in the case of Tunisia, where elections were recently delayed for three months, Egypt's delay was meant "to give a chance for those young political parties that had just been established to build grass roots," said Shadi Taha, a leader and spokesman for the Al Ghad Party, one of a coalition of 28 political groups who last week petitioned the military leadership to delay elections until November or December.
Mr. Taha said the continued political instability was part of the reason for the military council's decision "because as you know the situation right now is not stable at all in Tahrir Square and across the country," he said.
Even Egypt's most powerful Islamist party, the Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party, was among the 28-member coalition that pressed for an election delay.
Since the revolution, the Brotherhood has urged Egyptians to hew to the interim timetable set by the ruling Supreme Council of the Armed Forces. The Brotherhood's change of tack in the past few weeks is a further indication of the deepening uncertainty facing Egypt's democratic transition.
Essam El Erian, one of the leaders of Freedom and Justice, called the decision to delay "a good compromise" between his more well-established party and the newer political groups that sprung from the revolutionary ferment this year.
Protesters filled Tahrir Square this past Friday for a demonstration—dubbed "Revolution First"—meant to express frustration over the slow pace of political reform.
The Friday protest was mobilized in large part due to renewed violence in Tahrir Square last week between young activists and the reformed Egyptian police force that have been redeployed over the past several months.
Police officers disappeared from Egypt's streets during the revolution in February, but digital videos of riot police once again throwing rocks, beating and verbally taunting protesters has refocused Egyptians' anger on an institution many feel has yet to see true reform.
Mansour Al Essawy, Egypt's minister of interior, said Wednesday that 587 officers who were accused but not yet convicted of killing demonstrators during Egypt's revolution would be fired.
In his address to reporters Wednesday, Mr. Al Essawy said laws governing police forbid him from dismissing junior officers who are accused but not convicted of killing protesters. Those accused with ranks below brigadier general were "transferred to places where they won't deal with people," he said.
The protesters lingering in Tahrir Square who have made police reform a central demand said the announcement didn't go far enough.
"The vast majority of these defendants, these suspects, are still in active duty while they're being tried for murder," said Hossam Bahgat, director general of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, a Cairo-based nongovernmental organization that monitors police brutality.
While Mr. Bahgat acknowledged that Mr. Al Essawy was not legally allowed to dismiss low-ranking officers who haven't been convicted, he can subject them to a "cautionary suspension" until they are "either convicted or exonerated."
Mr. Bahgat said about 150 officers are currently facing trial for their role in the deaths of more than 800 protesters during Egypt's revolution.
But Mr. Bahgat's group has demanded that prosecutors reevaluate cases for hundreds of officers who tortured and abused witnesses and suspects before the revolution and that they, too, should be subject to suspension and termination.
Such officers remain in their jobs, where they can continue to intimidate witnesses, manipulate evidence and torture suspects, he said.
"Without police reform, this revolution will simply fail," Mr. Bahgat said. "That's why there is now this same sense of expectation—the same sense of waiting—that we felt immediately after Mubarak was unseated."
|
(Ahlul Bayt News Agency) - Officials of Al-Azhar University agreed to open a center for translation of Islamic works into Arabic at the central university located in Cairo.Having held a meeting chaired by Ahmad Al-Tayyeb, Sheikh of Al-Azhar, the Supreme Council of the university investigated the role of the university in dissemination of moderate Islamic thought.
The meeting was attended by Abdul Hamid Abu Suleiman, head of the World Center of Islamic Thought.
Discussing the formation of a center specialized for translation of Islamic works into Arabic, participants finally agreed to set up the center.
Launching of a Technological Nursing Center at the Specialized Hospital of the university in Nasr settlement in Cairo was also finalized at the program.
Officials of the council also decided to lift age limit for admission of non-Arabic speakers applying for studying at the university.
The council equally announced its readiness to cooperate with benevolent people in constructing charitable associations by offering its financial support.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
