Understanding the American Right

Opinion
What is the 'right' type of resistance?
Media coverage of the Palestinian resistance movement
is shaped to fit the Western narrative of nonviolence.
Over the past few months, several international media outlets have published articles fixating on the so-called "new" Palestinian nonviolent movement. Two fallacies have accompanied such reporting and analysis. First the use of the term "nonviolent" and its connotations; and second, the narrative surrounding the movement.

Unfortunately, the source of these articles is often respected media outlets that have reported fairly on the Palestinian cause, including Al Jazeera English.
The latest articles in the series are Al Jazeera English's "Green shoots emerge at Qalandia checkpoint",  the Economist blog's "Here comes your non-violent resistance",  and Time magazine's "Palestinian Border Protests: The Arab Spring model for confronting Israel".

The articles are replete with quotes such as "but the traditional resistance of burning tires and throwing stones will not change overnight. We need to give the world a picture of nonviolent Palestinian resistance", and "we're going to continue marching in nonviolence until it is very clear in the international media who is violating human rights".

#1: There is no such thing as Palestinian "nonviolent" resistance

To start with, the danger of using the term "nonviolent resistance" insinuates that any other form of resistance is violent, hence giving it a negative undertone.
In Arabic, Palestinians do not distinguish between violent and non-violent resistance, but rather between armed resistance and popular resistance. The Palestinian people and political factions have relied on both forms, as well as others, throughout the past century.
In fact, and unlike other colonial schemes in South Africa or Algeria, the goal of the Zionist colonial plan is to uproot and ethnically cleanse Palestine of its indigenous people - hence, by simply existing and standing firm on their land, Palestinians are actually resisting.

While I don't mean to advocate for a specific form of resistance here, there must be a clear distinction between two different notions.
On the one hand, there are attempts to impose the idea that nonviolence is the only form of resistance "allowed",  thus falsely implying that all other forms of resistance are violent, immoral or illegal. On the other hand, a general consensus views resistance as a legitimate right of the Palestinian people, as it is the right of any people living under oppression, colonisation and foreign occupation.
According to this view, popular resistance is perceived to be more effective than armed resistance at this stage of struggle. Because of the discrepancy between these two statements, the term "violent" has been extended to reach the throwing of stones at Israeli tanks or heavily armoured military checkpoints.
Many different forms of popular resistance characterised the first Intifada, including children jumping from house to house during curfew hours to provide sugar and flour to neighbors; youth playing soccer on the edges of streets so as to warn graffiti writers when a military vehicle was passing through; volunteer work; commercial strikes and boycotts; as well as mass protests that included throwing stones at army outposts and military vehicles.

The fact is, facing a brutal war machine with stones is but a symbolic gesture. It is a symbol of the vast discrepancy in power between the Palestinian people and Israel's war machine.
Stones aimed at Israeli tanks or other armed vehicles were a means for the unarmed indigenous people of Palestine to demonstrate their refusal of occupation and oppression. Youth, women, the elderly and all sectors of society participated in this form of resistance.
Stones could be violent, however, when used systematically by Israeli soldiers to smash Palestinians' limbs, as part of a policy ordered by Yitzhak Rabin, then Israeli minister of defence, to "break their bones". The Knesset refused to even investigate Rabin's order, and he was never been held accountable.

Moreover, media outlets advocating for these nonviolent tactics have chosen to completely overlook the Boycott Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel. Although it does not fall under the two forms of resistance mentioned earlier, it can be only be categorised as a strictly non-violent tactic, aiming to pressure Israel to abide by its obligations under international law.
The overwhelming growth in the BDS movement, met with little to no coverage of its successes by most mainstream media outlets can only be an indicator of the hypocrisy of their coverage of Palestinian resistance: only shedding light on forms of resistance they categorise as relevant - or, dare I say, worthy.

Finally, it is important to comprehend the context of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict that is often called "complex". In fact, and at the risk of oversimplifying, it is a conflict between an oppressor and an oppressed. Within that context the use of violence and force can be exemplified perfectly in the words of Paulo Freire:

"Never in history has violence been initiated by the oppressed. How could they be the initiators, if they themselves are the result of violence? How could they be the sponsors of something whose objective inauguration called forth their existence as oppressed? There would be no oppressed had there been no prior situation of violence to establish their subjugation. Violence is initiated by those who oppress, who exploit, who fail to recognise others as persons - not by those who are oppressed, exploited and unrecognised."  

#2: Western narrative and terminology

The second problem posed by this narrative and the discourse surrounding these articles is more significant and more worthy of criticism.
The articles present the current so-called nonviolent movement as the "correct" way to resist, where Palestinians' choice of the correct resistance method will demonstrate our worthiness to be given our rights and independence.

Portraying our rights to freedom and self determination as contingent upon our chosen method of resistance is at best inaccurate, and at worst rather racist.
Implying that our rights have not been fulfilled because we have not demonstrated our worthiness of them relieves Israel of the need to uphold international law and grant us our basic rights, and also excuses Western hegemonies for awarding Israel full impunity to carry on with its violations and crimes.
It must be made clear that our right to return and to end Israel's occupation, colonisation and apartheid are guaranteed by international conventions, and their fulfillment is an obligation - irrespective of the methods of resistance we choose to follow, or any other factors, for that matter.
In addition, suggesting that popular protest is a new phenomenon in Palestine where "the real Martin Luther King-style nonviolent Palestinian protestors have arrived" is a shameful distortion of facts by media outlets.
Resistance in Palestine, and particularly popular resistance, is more than a century old, where the overwhelming majority of resistance to Zionist colonisation, British rule, and later Israel's oppression has taken the form of civil,popular uprisings. Palestinian popular resistance can only be Palestinian-style! Journalists need to abandon lazy journalism, and expand their memory-span to more than ten years.

Thus we are allowed to follow Western values and figures, or the footsteps of those whoever they find acceptable, such as Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr (MLK). While everyone is waiting for the next "Palestinian Gandhi", what if we want a Palestinian Che Guevara or Malcolm X?
It was them, after all, who analysed and focused on the "international western power structure", a structure that has only developed in influence and tools since the 50s and 60s. And while having the utmost respect for the satyagrahaof Gandhi and MLK's battle in the civil rights movement, Palestinians need not look far to find role models within Palestine's history and heritage for alternative means of resistance.

In this issue, as in others, the hypocrisy of Western hegemonic powers is prevalent.
Democracy is only acceptable if the outcomes are what they have chosen - only neoliberal economic policies that please the real axis of evil (World Bank, International Monetary Fund, and the World Trade Organisation) are allowed in developing countries; and queer communities around the world must follow Western mechanisms of pride and advocacy. 
Though these are all apparently different issues, the same paradigm applies to all of them: Western hegemonic ideologies and forms of action are used to measure the legitimacy of others that are suggested around the world.

Particularly for Palestinians, narrative is one of the key issues.
Israel has the world in its hands, not because it is threatening them by force or military power, but because it controls the discourse. That is why when a group of Israelis harass Palestinians and plot to assassinate a head of mosque they are referred to in the media as "mobsters and gangs", or mentally unstable such as Baruch Goldstein - never as "terrorists" or "extremists".
This is similar to the indirect control processes applied throughout hundreds of years of colonialism, the same trope has been used to reinforce the coloniser's power: the primitive barbarians vs the enlightened people.
A recent ad campaign in the US demonstrates this, it reads: "In any war between the civilised man and the savage, support the civilised man. Support Israel. Defeat Jihad."

It is our role as Palestinians to be aware of the narrative distortions and to fight against that discourse. If we succeed, it would be much harder for someone such as Binyamin Netanyahu to humiliate the Palestinian people and the so-called Palestinian "leadership" in front of the US congress as he did so recently.

The 'right' form of resistance?

While there is no question that, within Palestinian society, all forms of resistance to oppression must be respected and valued, it is crucial not to be dragged into the Western narrative, especially since a large number of us among the nation's youth are already exposed to it by the media, the internet or via studying abroad.
The idea that there is only one "right" way of resistance or that armed and popular resistance are contradictory is false (or at least lacks historical evidence) if a simple review of colonial history is applied (Algeria, South Africa, etc).

The priority nowadays, indeed, should be to widely engage all movements, groups, and individuals in the demand to produce a new legitimate leadership institution that represents all Palestinians regardless of their venue. That body would be able to democratically (and internally) identify the most potent form of resistance.

In the aforementioned articles, Palestinian participants in popular protests are often quoted in a manner such as: "If some teenagers threw rocks, they had apparently failed to attend the workshops on nonviolence the organisers had arranged", and that they "insist no stones were thrown until Israeli troops fired tear gas, and then only by adolescents".
These statements show Palestinian protesters to be apologetic for the symbolic gesture of throwing stones - and this is at the expense of questioning the very presence of Israel's occupation forces.

History has shown that Israel's use of extreme violence is a constant - irrespective of the violent or nonviolent actions of Palestinians. It is crucial we realise that throughout the years of our struggle against Zionism and colonialism, the Zionist response to all the various forms of resistance was, in essence, the same - violence.
Sixty years ago, forty years ago, in the first and second Intifadas, and in the recent "peaceful" marches, the Israeli response was always violence and bloodshed - young men and women have been shot with live and rubber-coated ammunition, beaten with clubs and suffocated by toxic gas.
It would be naive to expect the Israeli response to differ in the future, nor would it be required to resist nonviolently to show the ugly face of Israeli occupation - since it is demonstrated in every single action of Palestinian daily life. 
Regardless of our strategy, Israel will continue to deny our existence as a nation, will not admit the ethnic cleansing it committed in 1948, and will continue its suppressive measures of oppression against Palestinians everywhere.
It is our role to focus on our similarities and points of agreement about resistance rather than our differences.
The Palestinian people must mobilise around resisting Israeli apartheid through a program that is generated from a discussion within a truly representative body - which is only possible through direct elections for a new Palestinian National Council (PNC).
Ibrahim Shikaki is a UC Berkeley graduate. He works as an associate researcher at the Palestine Economic Research Institute (MAS) and is a Ramallah-based youth organiser.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily represent Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

July 06, 2011

Protests Erupt in Egypt Over Police Trials

Protesters and military police tussle over trying to overturn a police car after protesters broke the windows in front of the court complex in Suez, Egypt, July 6, 2011

Protesters and military police tussle over trying to overturn
a police car after protesters broke the windows in front
of the court complex in Suez, Egypt, July 6, 2011
Hundreds of Egyptians carried out a violent protest Wednesday, after a court upheld a ruling to release at least 10 policemen accused of killing demonstrators during this year's anti-government uprising.

Protesters threw stones at the government security building in the city of Suez and attacked a courthouse. They also damaged police vehicles.

There were no reports of injuries.

The protest is part of growing dissent against Egypt's military rulers.  Some Egyptians say they are frustrated with what they perceive as the rulers' reluctance to prosecute officials from former president Hosni Mubarak's government who are accused of violence against demonstrators.

As tensions rose Wednesday, Egypt's security chief said he will dismiss hundreds of policemen for their role in the deadly crackdown on anti-government protests earlier this year.  Interior Minister Mansour el-Essawi said the move, planned for mid-July, will be the largest police shakeup in Egypt's history.

Egyptian activists are calling for a huge rally in Cairo's Tahrir Square on Friday to show their discontent with the court decisions that sparked Wednesday's protests.  The Muslim Brotherhood - Egypt's most organized opposition group - has announced plans to attend.

On Monday, hundreds of Egyptians attacked a Cairo courthouse after a judge ordered seven policemen charged with killing 17 anti-government demonstrators to be freed on bail until their September trials.  Three other police officers are being tried in absentia in the case.

Last week, more than 1,000 people were injured in confrontations between police and protesters in Cairo.  Some protesters had been demanding the country's military leadership speed up the prosecutions of officials blamed for the deadly crackdown on anti-government demonstrators.
Some information for this report was provided by AP, AFP and Reuters.
Intellectuals praise Al-Azhar Document
Intellectuals at a symposium Friday night stressed the need to build Egypt's future on strong democratic and national foundations. During the symposium, which took place at the El-Sennary House in Cairo, participants warned that both secular and religious governments could bring dictators to power.  They discussed the Al-Azhar Document, a set of recommendations issued last week by Al-Azhar, Egypt's most prominent Islamic institution, and said it upholds the value of a national state based on democratic principles. Participants said that the document restores Al-Azhar's historical independence. The institution was under the control of the former regime for the past three decades. Some participants criticized the document, however, for containing an article that permits the unrestricted practice of religious rites. Salah Fadl, a critic and one of the thinkers who prepared the Al-Azhar Document, said that it confirms Al-Azhar's respect for values and ideals. The institution has been regarded as a symbol of enlightenment and moderate Islam throughout history, he said, and the document will help it regain its former prominence. He said that the document, which has won a near consensus among people and intellectuals, is the only document to have received such a favorable response. Fadl said the document calls for the independence of Al-Azhar and the restoration of the Supreme Clerics Council. Mohamed Kamal al-Din Imam, also involved in preparing the document, expressed his delight with intellectuals' responses and their keenness on maintaining Al-Azhar's important role in Islamic affairs. He added that because the document is primarily cultural and intellectual rather than doctrinal, it was not submitted to the Islamic Research Academy. Columnist Helmy al-Nemnim, who also participated in drafting the document, said it is not binding and only reflects the opinion of those who prepared it. He said Egypt's cabinet may use it as a reference, especially since 18 political parties will announce their support of it. He said Egypt should not be a secular state ruled by a dictator as in Libya, Iraq and Syria, or an oppressive religious state such as Iran. Nemnim concluded that the solution lies in the creation of "a democratic state that does not allow the creation of a dictator," and that the Al-Azhar Document reflects moderate Islam adopted by both Al-Azhar and ordinary Egyptians. Among those who participated in the symposium were former Muslim Brotherhood leader and presidential candidates Abdel Moneim Abouel Fotouh, Professor Mohamed Aboul Ghar, and Professor Hossam Eissa.<p></p>
Translated from the Arabic Edition
Key US lawmaker condemns Muslim Brotherhood talks
WASHINGTON — A key US lawmaker on Friday condemned contacts between President Barack Obama's administration and Egypt's once-banned Muslim Brotherhood, warning the group aims to impose strict Islamist law.
"I strongly disagree with the Obama Administration's contacts with the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood," said Republican Steve Chabot, who chairs the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on the Middle East and South Asia.
"The United States should be doing everything it can to support secular democratic opposition groups instead of groups like the Muslim Brotherhood with the proclaimed objective of establishing Sharia law," he said in a statement.
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said during a visit to Budapest on Thursday that Washington had been in "limited contacts" with the group as part of an effort to adjust to Egypt's political upheaval.
"The Obama administration is continuing the approach of limited contacts with the Muslim Brotherhood that have existed on and off for about five or six years," she told journalists.
"We believe that given the change of the political landscape in Egypt, it is in the interest of the United States to engage with all parties that are peaceful and committed to non-violence," she said.
"This is not a new policy but it is one that we're re-engaging in."
Chabot said Washington had "a clear interest in the emergence of a democratic and prosperous Egypt" because Egypt's future will have "a disproportionate impact on the future of the broader Middle East."
The lawmaker said the United States should be pushing for democratic and free-market reforms in Egypt, and said one key goal was seeing its government respect the country's peace treaty with Israel.